by Citizens for Global Solutions | Nov 3, 2009 | Climate Justice, Global Cooperation
Today is a momentous day for global warming legislation, as the markup in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee is scheduled to begin. Yet, the day is tainted by the fact that the Republican Party plans to boycott the markup all together. Not one of the seven Republicans on the panel plans to attend the meeting.
Under such circumstances, one cannot help but think back to just a few decades ago, when the Republicans were at the forefront of environmental legislation. In a speech last Thursday, Senator Barbara Boxer noted “The interesting thing is most of these environmental laws started with a Republican president named Richard Nixon. What happened to the days when environmental laws were supported on both sides? Those days appear to be gone.”
Senator Boxer makes a good point. The Clean Water Act of 1972 was a product of bipartisan effort and ultimately signed into law by President Nixon. The Clean Air Act of 1970 and Amendments of 1990 were again pursued by Republicans. A notice released by the EPA in 1990 about the Clean Air Act noted, “Through his leadership, the President (George H. W. Bush) broke the 13-year clean air stalemate by submitting an innovative, market-based bill which will achieve the nation’s environmental goals in the most effective manner.” Thus, it is evident that there was a time in which Republicans took the initiative to pursue environmental legislation. This created a bipartisan environment in which both parties could work together to pass legislation that could actually make a difference.
Now, just a few decades later, the story is completely different as the Republicans refuse to participate in the global warming legislation markup entirely. They have their reasons of course, including their claim that they were not given complete information from the EPA and the Congressional Budget Office. Yet, regardless, their refusal to participate seems a bit stubborn. Senator Boxer noted that it would be in “remarkably bad faith” for the Republicans to stay away from the markup.
All this conflict is enough to make one long for the good old days, when the parties just got along. At least when it came to climate change legislation.
by Anu Joshi | Nov 3, 2009 | Climate Justice, Global Cooperation

Here are some pictures that Tom Hastings took at the Climate Action Day, Oct 24, at Manhattan Beach. This world-wide event was organized by the 350 Organization (http://www.350.org). The purpose was to raise awareness of the goal to reduce CO2 in the atmosphere to 350 parts per million in order for the climate to be sustainable. CO2 is currently at 390 ppm and rising 2 ppm each year.
The CGS table manned by Becky Tan and Tom Hastings on Climate Action Day, Saturday, October 24, at Manhattan Beach. They got over twenty attendees to fill out postcards and address them to Senators Boxer and Feinstein and to President Obama:
There was a long line showing where high tide will be on Manhattan Beach if we don’t bring CO2 down to 350 parts per million:
by Vinay Orekondy | Nov 2, 2009 | Climate Justice

“No to climate government takeover!!!”
I never thought I’d agree with a tea party activist. And I’m not really sure if what I’m about to say actually qualifies as agreement. But that there might be any kind of common ground at all between me and this balding, burly, red-faced conservative spitting on my television screen is an endearing, if mildly frightening prospect.
For the record, I am a staunch supporter of a strong climate bill. But like the angry tea party activist, I heavily oppose a ‘government takeover’ of the climate change issue.
Climate change is completely different to any other problem that we face. It is not merely a case of curbing/banning certain forms of behavior, although that is definitely part of it. Nor is it merely about adaptation, although that too is surely critical. Ultimately, it is a total transformation of how our society thinks on a deeply fundamental level. In this case, it is our society’s relationship with the environment – after centuries of building up a wall in our collective conscience between our world and the environment, we are being forced to realize that we are actually part of it. Armed with this new mindset, we’re no longer capable of that perverse existential separation, where we see the universe through the lens of a single individual existing only in the present time. We are forced to transcend on some level, and to look through the lens of the world until the end of time. We must look at our everyday actions and ask “Is this an action which can be repeated indefinitely, by anyone, anywhere?”
Now unless we lived in a 1984-style totalitarian state where the government controlled how we think, this kind of change simply cannot be driven by the government. It is change of the incremental variety, the kind which can only truly come from the bottom up. Day by day, little by little, individuals and organizations will create the innovations which make our society more sustainable.
Thus a government takeover of climate change would be bad news not because it did too much, but because it did too little. The only way we can truly re-engineer society is to do so with the one thing which undoubtedly touches every one of us – the free market. I truly believe that ‘green innovations’ will become a massive source of profit over the decades to come.
Yet I mentioned earlier that I support a strong climate bill. Legislation will help curb the worst of our actions, and provide a broad framework in which a transformation can begin to occur. It is merely a catalyst, whose job is to merely make things easier for the innovators who will generate true change on the issue. Without this single piece of collective action, individual action is extremely hard – the system is simply not designed to think in environmental terms. Those individuals and organizations that do buck the trend and show environmental leadership may be doing so at their own expense.
This is why the whole free market versus government debate is truly missing the point. Both have absolutely critical roles to play in this process. The great champion of the free market, Ayn Rand, wrote that it is the unrestrained power of the individual which has always made society great. I agree. But I would respond by saying that it is the role of society to define what greatness is.
And so this is my call to the conservative wing of politics – to be a part of this process. Not to repeat tired lines of argument, such as denying global warming or support drilling and nuclear energy, but to be part of conceptualizing a new economy, one which is more profitable and sustainable than ever before. You have something to offer that many on the left do not – the ability to see great potential in the free market. By joining in the process of crafting and supporting strong climate change legislation, you can be part of ensuring core conservative principles – the ideas of self-reliance, competition and innovation – remain a foundational part of the new economy for years to come.
by Citizens for Global Solutions | Oct 23, 2009 | Climate Justice, Global Cooperation
The House passed its version of climate legislation, the Waxman Markey Bill, in June, despite being criticized alternately for not doing enough and for doing too much to stop climate change. The Senate finally released its own version, the Kerry-Boxer Bill, last month, and now the same debates have started again.
A few differences between the bills are notable. The House bill sought to cut emissions by 17% of 2005 levels by 2020, while Senate bill aims to raise this to 20% of 2005 levels by 2020. However, the long-term targets of both bills are the same at this time: 42% by 2030 and 83% by 2050. The Senate Bill preserves the Environmental Protection Agency’s authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, a provision lauded by environmentalists. Both bills cap carbon offsets at 2 billion tons per year, but the Senate bill seems to go further in making sure that the offsets are credible and effective. Also, nuclear energy is dealt with more in the Senate bill by devoting a section to promote the deployments of nuclear power plants.
Senators Kerry and Boxer have described their legislation as a “first step,” as they wish to add and change many provisions in their attempts to secure votes for the legislation’s passage. But the draft legislation is not the only first step to be taken. Passing climate legislation in the U.S. itself is just one step. Of course, neither of the bills are going to solve the problem. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has estimated that emissions need to be reduced to 25%-40% below 1990 levels by 2020 in order to revert the worst effects of climate change, which is already responsible for over 300,000 deaths a year according to the Global Humanitarian Forum. The Senate bill only reduces emissions to 7% of 1990 levels by 2020.
But we have to start somewhere. The Kerry-Boxer bill creates the foundation for stronger environmental action in the future by setting up systems and offices to deal with climate change mitigation. Moreover, Senators Boxer and Kerry said that the implementation of the bill would lead to the creation of 1.9 million jobs in the U.S., all without adding a single penny to the deficit. Senator Kerry has also noted that the energy market is a 6 trillion dollar market with about 4.5 billion eligible users. Transitioning to a clean energy economy not only takes the urgently needed step of combating climate change, it also represents opportunities for the future. It is time for Senators on both sides of the isle to unite in the fight against climate change, one step at a time.
by Citizens for Global Solutions | Oct 22, 2009 | Climate Justice, Global Cooperation
The United Nations Climate Conference in Copenhagen is set for December 7th through December 18th 2009. The main goal of this conference is to create an international treaty that establishes a global climate agreement to replace the Kyoto Protocol which expires in 2012. The target of the Kyoto Protocol was to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by an average of 5.2% of 1990 levels by 2010.
The Kyoto Protocol was important because it set international standards and commitments for greenhouse gas emissions which demonstrated an international effort to protect the environment. It is crucial that the U.N. Climate Conference in Copenhagen ends with a treaty because the work that has been started to combat global warming is not yet over. Without a comprehensive and binding treaty, it cannot be possible to expect countries to commit to long-term emission reductions.
The United States has an especially important role in the Copenhagen conference. The U.S. has the chance to be a leader at this conference. However, the legitimacy of this leadership is heavily tied to domestic policy in America. It is important for the U.S. to pass domestic legislation that sets targets for emission reductions before Copenhagen. However, any legislation passed should show a serious dedication to cutting emissions. The American Clean Energy and Security Act, passed in May 2009, aims to reduce emissions by 4% of 1990 levels, and the Boxer-Kerry bill has proposed to cut emissions by 7% of 1990 levels. But, the scientific community has asserted that a 40% reduction of 1990 levels is necessary to really make a difference. While it is important to see the U.S. taking steps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, the proposed reductions are a very small margin of what is actually needed to effect global climate change. For the United States to take a real leadership role in the battle against climate change, higher emissions reduction commitments are absolutely necessary.
The United States is one of the highest emitters of carbon dioxide in the world; however the effects of climate change are ever-present in developing countries that have very small emissions. The upcoming conference in Copenhagen will hopefully yield positive results, but it is critical for the U.S. to ratify and enforce any new treaty that is created. It is time for the United States to take responsibility for the damage it has done and commit to more significant reductions in emissions.
by Citizens for Global Solutions | Oct 21, 2009 | Climate Justice, Global Cooperation

A key component of the Boxer-Kerry Bill is a policy called “cap-and-trade.” “Cap-and-trade” is a method that provides an economic incentive for the greenhouse-gas-emitting entities to reduce their emissions. More specifically, the policy identifies the entities and gives them a set allowance for their emissions. The sum of all the greenhouse gas emitted by all the entities equals the national cap. In return, the entities are allowed to trade their allowance credits amongst themselves for a profit.
While the Boxer-Kerry Bill includes this policy, it shies away from the term “cap-and-trade,” referring to it instead as the “pollution reduction and investment” program. Why did they change the wording of the policy? A historical analogy of the policy to the Slave Trade Act of 1807 may provide a clue. This act abolished the Atlantic slave trade, yet did not abolish the act of slavery itself. Thus, no more slaves could enter America, but the preexisting slaves could be traded amongst the plantation owners as much as they pleased. Sounds very similar to a “cap-and-trade” policy. This allows a possible comparison between the two, as they could be viewed as easy ways to deal with external pressure while really ignoring the larger issues at hand. This analogy may explain why the Boxer-Kerry Bill has avoided the term “cap-and-trade.” Avoiding the term may mean avoiding the comparison. And they don’t want to be viewed as taking the easy way out. Smart move.
Yet, despite the negative associations with the term “cap-and-trade,” it is important to note that the policy has the potential for success. There are several historical examples of successful “cap-and-trade” policies, including the Clear Air Act Amendments. These were passed in 1990 by George H.W. Bush in an effort to reduce sulfur emission as the effects of acid rain were brought to the public’s attention. Just like in the Boxer-Kerry Bill, each sulfur producing entity was assigned a cap, but they were allowed to trade or sell unused allowances for a profit. This program was extremely success. It received 100 percent compliance in reducing sulfur dioxide emissions and by 2002, sulfur emissions were 41% lower than in 1980.
Thus, the “cap-and-trade” policy of the Boxer-Kerry Bill has great potential for success. Past “cap-and-trade” policies on the environment have been very successful, despite certain negative historical associations with the term. It is important to look past the term and see the policy in all its potential. Yet, the bill faces strong opposition that does not need more fuel for its fire. Using the term “pollution reduction and investment” rather than “cap-and-trade” definitely won’t hurt. After all, no bill wants to be compared to a slave law.