Skip to content

Copenhagen Climate Talks- Talking the Same Language

The Copenhagen climate talks began today amid much excitement, anxiety and hope. As representatives from around the world negotiate key issues such as emissions reduction commitments and monetary assistance to developing countries, they should keep in mind one goal that will facilitate the agreement to and monitoring of all other climate deals: establishing a common metrics for measuring and declaring emissions reductions.

Citizens for Global Solutions has advocated the establishment of such a common metrics, and today the Washington Post released an article making the same point. Fredd Krupp of the Environmental Defense Fund said that climate change mitigation efforts should be “measured in the same units — tons of carbon” in order to facilitate private capital investments for mitigation funds to assist developing countries. This editorial demonstrated one of the many beneficial effects of setting a standard of how to measure emissions reductions.

Currently, countries use different methods of measurement when announcing climate change action. Most use a percentage reduction in emissions below a base year, but even the base year used by countries is not uniform. For example, the U.S. has announced targets of reducing emissions to 17% below 2005 levels by 2020, and the European Union has talked about accepting cuts of 30% below 1990 by 2020. Moreover, when individual countries make commitments in terms of percentage reductions, it is extremely difficult to calculate how close the total global emissions reductions are to the level that the scientific community says we need to achieve to avert the worst effects of climate change. Setting a common language to speak about emissions reductions needs to be on the Copenhagen Agenda!

Read more here

China Announces Carbon Intensity Reduction Goals: Why We Need More

China Announces Carbon Intensity Reduction Goals: Why We Need More

The climate talks in Copenhagen received a positive push this week, but we need to push further still. The governments of U.S. and China have announced that their heads of state will be representing their countries in Copenhagen, and that they will bring reduction commitments to the table. These are encouraging steps, but much more needs to be achieved in Copenhagen. For one, China’s goals to mitigate climate change have been expressed in terms of reducing carbon intensity, rather than in terms of reducing the amount of emissions released. China has announced a goal to reduce its carbon intensity to 40-45% below 2005 levels by 2020, but this method of measurement entails much uncertainty. Carbon intensity measures the amount of carbon emitted per unit of energy consumed, and reductions in it do not necessarily result in emissions reductions. What matters to reduce global warming is that the total amount of emissions reduces, not the efficiency with which carbon is used. Carbon intensity could fall with more efficient use of carbon, but the total amount of carbon emissions actually released could increase at the same time. This is the danger of using such measures for reductions in climate change- they could be misleading and counterproductive.

The Copenhagen summit should standardize measures for climate change mitigation action. This standard metrics can be measuring the amount of carbon emissions reduced in metric tons. This way, commitments of various countries can be easily compared, and the global community can estimate how close the combined reductions commitments of all countries are to reaching the goal that the scientific community has said we need to achieve in order to avert the worst effects of climate change: reducing total emissions to 13-16 billion metric tons by 2020. This is a much more concrete measure than China’s carbon intensity standards in terms of its comparability and indication of the absolute amount of carbon emissions released. If this is not established soon, other countries may follow China’s lead in using potentially misleading measures for climate change mitigation action.

Obama to go to Copenhagen!

Obama to go to Copenhagen!

Giving a boost to the upcoming Copenhagen climate talks, the White House has announced that President Obama himself will be attending the negotiations that aim to develop an international climate change agreement. An administration official has also revealed that Obama will commit to cutting U.S. emissions to 17% below 2005 levels by 2020, the target of the House bill (Waxman-Markey bill) that was passed this June. This is a bold and important step, necessary to counter the pessimism of many about the speculated productivity of the talks, the delay in passing climate legislation in the U.S. Senate, the statements by Senator Inhofe (R-OK) about bringing a “truth squad” to Copenhagen to show the world what is “really” happening in the U.S. in terms of willingness and capacity to enact climate legislation, and the stalemate between developing and developed countries about financial assistance and binding emissions reduction commitments.

The President’s presence has given renewed momentum to the upcoming summit. It is crucial that the negotiations continue with everyone at the table, including countries at all levels of development. To do this, the demands of developed countries for developing countries to commit to binding emissions reduction targets on one hand, and the demands of developing countries for developed countries to provide financial aid for such measures on the other, will have to be addressed in some way. As of now, the European Union seems more inclined to give such aid than the U.S. is. Countries like China have demanded 1% of the GDP from developed countries for these purposes. Even if such commitments cannot be made this year, the process of finding a deal could continue with Obama’s presence signaling U.S. commitment to act on this front, and with the U.S. providing incentives such as subsidized clean energy technology transfers to developing countries that have taken demonstrated efforts to adopt a clean development path.

It is a welcome sign that our President will be joining the roughly 65 other heads of state in Copenhagen, but the road ahead is still long. The emissions reduction that the U.S. is agreeing to is roughly 4-7% below 1990 levels by 2020, whereas developing countries and the scientific community have said that developed countries need to cut emissions by 25-40% below 1990 levels by 2020. Though this gap is large, the process must continue, so that the next climate summit scheduled for 2010 in Mexico City will be more fruitful. At this point, developed countries can set emissions reductions commitments, developing countries can agree to lower their emissions increases, and developed countries can work together to help fund such changes in developing countries. This is a strong place to start, and at the very least, this much must be agreed to now.

After Copenhagen, Obama’s next stop will be Norway, to formally accept his Nobel Peace Prize- where he will now have one more contribution to speak of.

Read more here

Copenhagen: A disappointment waiting to happen?

Many thought that the upcoming Copenhagen conference next month would lead to a global agreement on climate change. However, it seems as though we will have to wait a little longer.

Last week, the major world leaders met in Singapore to discuss the purpose of Copenhagen. Deciding to delay the establishment of a comprehensive and binding treaty, they instead agreed that the mission of the conference would be a less specific “politically binding” agreement. According to a New York Times article, this agreement “punts the most difficult issues into the future.”

According to the leaders involved with this decision, this is for the sake of Copenhagen. Michael Froman, the deputy national security adviser for international economic affairs, stated, “It is unrealistic to expect a fully internationally, legally binding agreement could be negotiated between now and Copenhagen, which starts in 22 days.” According to Froman, forcing an agreement upon the world now would be counterproductive to global climate change cooperation.

However, others can see through this argument. An article in the Washington Post referred to it as a “pathetic spin.” Copenhagen has been on the calendar for years and shouldn’t have surprised anyone. We all knew it was coming, and we all should have been prepared.

Regardless of the validity of this argument, the delay is disappointing to all who were expecting great accomplishments from Copenhagen. Now the comprehensive treaty discussion has to wait, at least until the second summit meeting in Mexico City. Let us hope that a delay isn’t issued right before that meeting as well.

Do too much = boycott at home. Do too little = boycott abroad

Do too much = boycott at home. Do too little = boycott abroad

As the scientific community has united in its call for drastic action to reduce global warming, which is already claiming hundreds of thousands of lives, the U.S. and the international community seems to have reached a stalemate. This week, the Kerry-Boxer climate bill markup was boycotted by republicans, and in deciding to continue with the markup anyway, Senator Boxer may have antagonized republicans beyond repair. Talks about a new compromise bill in the Senate have already begun. While some in the US fear that pursuing 4-7% emissions reductions below 1990 levels by 2020 (as the Kerry-Boxer bill does) will harm the economy too much through the measures laid out in the legislation, countries abroad are staging boycotts of their own because they want the US to commit to a 40% reduction below 1990 levels by 2020. The math is easy: the gap between what the US seems to find acceptable and what the international community seeks is immense.

These issues came to light as the climate talks in Barcelona drew to a close this week. Developing countries repeated their demand for assistance from developed countries in taking environmental action. They argue that developing countries used cheaper, quicker, and environmentally degrading methods to boost growth. If other nations are to be denied this opportunity, they want the first polluters to compensate them. But debates in the US Senate bring up the other side: that strong measures in one country alone will not solve the problem. Calls are being made in the US Senate for a bill that does not kick in unless other countries also commit to binding emissions reductions. On the other end, the G77, a coalition of developing countries, said: “Individual pledges (of the industrialized countries to reduce their GHG emissions) add up to only 11-18% below 1990 levels by 2020 if we include US. Such a low level is unacceptable. It takes us on a dangerous path. We need a real change of heart and mind by developed countries. It has to be demonstrated by (putting up) figures. It is not sufficient to have progressive and noble rhetoric which is empty.” To focus attention on this, fifty African countries boycotted part of the Barcelona summit.

To pass a climate bill, the Senate needs 60 votes. To pass an international treaty, the Senate needs 67. Now, many fear that the US will not be able to go into the Copenhagen climate talks next month and make any firm commitments because it could not even pass domestic legislation. Senator Kerry, the bill’s co-author, admitted: “We have to be honest in the process and deal with the realities that we don’t have time in these four weeks to put the language together and flesh out every crossed t and dotted i of a treaty.”

Where does this leave us now? Of course, it would have been ideal to have a bipartisan piece of US legislation to boast when going into Copenhagen. But there is still common ground to be sought. Fighting climate change is in everyone’s interest: rich countries and poor countries, republicans and democrats. On their own, both developed and developing countries have taken significant steps to combat climate change- whether by boosting wind power in China or by committing to high emissions reductions in the EU. On their own, both republicans and democrats have introduced and championed climate change legislation. At this time of seemingly severe divides, perhaps we need to take a moment to start from scratch and rebuild the dialogue and rhetoric with a strong foundation: that of what we have done individually, and what will happen to us all if we don’t do more together.

The Problem With Sustainable Development

The Problem With Sustainable Development

As the clock on the Kyoto Protocol is ticking down to expiration, the importance of the upcoming U.N. Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen is growing. A multilateral, enforceable treaty, setting limits on carbon emissions would be the ideal outcome. However, as the dates for the conference are getting closer, the actual goals are getting smaller. On October 28, 2008, U.N. Secretary General, Ban Ki-moon said that the conference could still be a success without its creation of a legally binding agreement. He encouraged ambitious political agreements, with details to be worked out later. Part of the reason for this is because of the current conflict between developing and developed nations.

It is no secret that developed nations have much larger emissions than developing countries. However, the effects of these emissions are hard-hitting on the developing nations, the ones that often do not have the resources to provide health care to their people, let alone fight the negative impacts of climate change. In the meantime, developed countries are trying to enforce “sustainable” development around the world so that the inevitable increase in carbon emissions from industrialization does not occur as development progresses. However, a major paradigm in the development field is that economic growth must be a priority, and the environment can be fixed later when development has been achieved. Also, the current developed countries certainly did not even consider sustainable development during their plight for economic growth. While I do not ascribe to this vision of development (and I do believe more and more people are starting to see the problems with this type of thinking), it is a standpoint that many nations have taken. In the meantime, the developed world is trying to stop unsustainable development so that the damage done by the developed world in achieving economic growth does not occur in this new push for development. While, I do believe it is crucial to regulate emissions in the developing world, what gives the developed world the moral authority to intervene and tell these struggling countries what to do? Development has been riddled by failed foreign intervention, and massive international aid projects that do not get resources to the right people. For years, the West has been telling developing nations what they need, instead of actually asking these nations what is important to them, is it really going to be any different this time around?

In saying this, I am not saying that developing countries do not care about the environment, because that is simply not true. I am saying that the developed world’s push to force sustainable development on poor countries may not be the best approach. There are probably local, sustainable development movements in the vast majority of countries, such as the Landless Workers Movement (MST) in Brazil, or Navdanya in India. Perhaps the best way to reduce carbon emissions globally is not to enforce strict measures on the developing world (that they may not be able to meet), but to support local movements that are fighting the causes of environmental degradation and climate change in their regions. These movements are usually not only environmental movements, but also fights for equality and human rights in regions were the poor are continuously marginalized. By supporting these movements, the developed world can not only take a stand against climate change, but also against persistent injustices in the developing world.