Skip to content
Andrew Igdal Wins the 2026 New Voices 4 Global Solutions Essay Contest

Andrew Igdal Wins the 2026 New Voices 4 Global Solutions Essay Contest

His winning essay argues that the world’s shipping lanes are guaranteed by law and protected by no one in particular, and that a clause of the UN Charter nobody has ever used is the way to fix it.

Andrew Igdal has won the 2026 New Voices 4 Global Solutions Essay Contest for “Room to Maneuver: The Case for a UN Maritime Force Under Article 109.”

Eighty percent of world trade by volume moves by sea, and most of it squeezes through a handful of narrow passages. The Strait of Malacca alone carries 23.7 percent of seaborne trade volume. The Strait of Hormuz carries 11.1 percent. The Suez Canal carries roughly 10 percent. Igdal’s essay starts from a question that sounds simple and turns out not to be: who is responsible for keeping those routes open?

The legal answer is that nobody in particular is. The 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea established freedom of navigation as a right and created no mechanism to enforce it. Enforcement was left to flag states, and many of the states where the world’s merchant fleet is registered have, in the words of a House of Lords committee, no meaningful capacity to enforce anything. Igdal calls this the Charter’s most consequential and under-appreciated gap.

The costs of that gap are measurable. Recent disruption in the Red Sea cut traffic through the Suez Canal by 90 percent and added roughly a million dollars to the cost of a single voyage. Freight costs rose more than 40 percent and transit times stretched from two weeks to over a month when the International Rescue Committee suspended its humanitarian shipping route to Sudan. In Yemen, where food insecurity threatens half of a population of roughly 34 million, sea-freighted cargo delivered by the UN World Food Programme fell 81 percent year over year.

The essay also traces what happens when protection is provided and then withdrawn. During the Somali piracy crisis, around 90 percent of World Food Programme aid to Somalia arrived by sea. Naval escorts began in November 2007, and no escorted WFP ship was ever attacked. When the escorts lapsed in mid-2008, shippers refused to load WFP cargo for Somalia at all. Igdal’s conclusion is blunt: armed protection of humanitarian sea corridors works, and without it the corridors collapse.

His proposal is a new chapter of the UN Charter establishing a standing maritime collective security organization with three mandates. It would protect freedom of navigation at designated chokepoints, secure humanitarian maritime corridors when disruption risks mass civilian harm, and provide shared surveillance and response against maritime coercion by state and non-state actors. It would run on two layers: a persistent network of uncrewed surface vessels, aerial drones, and shared monitoring systems, and a rotating conventional fleet contributed by member states, with command rotating among contributing regions rather than sitting permanently with one capital. Funding would be assessed in proportion to each member’s share of global seaborne trade by volume, so that the countries most dependent on open sea lanes carry a share of the cost that matches the benefit they receive.

The mechanism is Article 109 of the UN Charter, which allows member states to convene a general conference to review the Charter in full. It was also the subject of this year’s contest theme, “From Charter to Change: Reimagining Global Governance through Article 109,” which asked entrants to name the limits of the current UN system and propose one specific reform a general conference could adopt. The framers expected Article 109 to be used early in the organization’s life. It has never been used once. Citizens for Global Solutions treats it as a live legal mechanism rather than a historical curiosity and has made the case for its use a priority of its current work, including a 2027 special edition of Mondial devoted to Charter review.

Igdal grew up in the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains in western North Carolina. He holds bachelor’s degrees in physics and economics from NC State University and is now a PhD student in public policy at the University of Texas at Austin’s LBJ School of Public Affairs, where he is part of the Webber Energy Group and researches the economics of electrical transmission infrastructure and residential electrification programs. Outside his academic work he spends time with family, plays basketball, backpacks, rock climbs, reads and writes, and keeps a deliberate connection to rural communities and to the question of how energy and sustainability work reaches places that have been underserved by it.

“While my typical focus is on US energy systems, I’m grateful and excited for the opportunity to listen to and learn from folks focused on important global issues and solutions and chip in my perspective,” Igdal said.

The prize is an all-expenses-paid trip to the 42nd Ventotene International Federalist Seminar, held from 30 August to 4 September on the island of Ventotene in the Tyrrhenian Sea. Organized by the Altiero Spinelli Institute for Federalist Studies, the seminar brings students, young professionals, academics, and policymakers from around the world together for a week of lectures, policy workshops, and debate on democracy, European integration, and global governance.

Ventotene is where Altiero Spinelli and Ernesto Rossi were held as political prisoners by the Italian government during the Second World War, and where they drafted the Ventotene Manifesto, which argued for a federal Europe as a way to prevent future wars. The document became a foundation text for European integration.

Igdal’s essay will also appear in Mondial, the journal CGS co-publishes with World Federalist Movement Canada, in the 2027 print edition devoted to Charter review.

Read “Room to Maneuver: The Case for a UN Maritime Force Under Article 109” in full.

__

New Voices 4 Global Solutions is the annual essay contest of Citizens for Global Solutions, open to US-based students aged 18 to 30. Entries were judged on responsiveness to the theme, depth of analysis, originality, clarity of writing, use of credible sources, and respect for differing viewpoints. The prize is an all-expenses-paid trip to the Ventotene International Federalist Seminar and publication in Mondial. Views expressed in contest entries are the author’s own.

Room to Maneuver: The Case for a UN Maritime Force Under Article 109

Room to Maneuver: The Case for a UN Maritime Force Under Article 109

From raw materials and food staples, to advanced manufactured goods and life-saving humanitarian supplies, 12.3 billion tons of goods move by sea each year—a nearly fivefold increase from 2.6 billion tons in 1970, and the highest volume in recorded history (UNCTAD, 2018, 2024). This level of trade is facilitated largely by the expectation that shipping lanes remain open and free. Yet, this expectation may not always hold, and disruptions to sea lanes can have far-reaching, long-lasting, and unevenly experienced impacts.

During the eight years that the Suez Canal was closed between 1967 and 1975, trade between countries whose shipping routes depended on the canal fell by roughly one-fifth (Feyrer, 2009). For every dollar that was lost in trade, national incomes across the affected countries contracted by 25 cents (Feyrer, 2009).

Today, over 80% of world trade by volume moves by sea (UNCTAD, 2018). Much of this trade concentrates through a handful of chokepoints—the Strait of Malacca carries 23.7% of seaborne trade volume, the Strait of Hormuz 11.1%, and the Suez Canal roughly 10% (UNCTAD, 2024)—making the entire system vulnerable to disruption at just a few narrow passages. Recent disruptions in the Red Sea caused by the Houthis, a Yemeni armed group controlling much of northern Yemen, reduced Suez traffic by 90%, added approximately $1 million per voyage in rerouting costs, and may have increased global consumer prices by approximately 0.6% (Defense Intelligence Agency, 2024; UNCTAD, 2024).

And more than just merchant trade is disrupted. Freight costs rose more than 40% and transit times increased from two weeks to over a month when the International Rescue Committee (IRC) suspended the humanitarian shipping route through the Red Sea to Sudan (Yusuf, 2024). In Yemen, where food insecurity threatens half of the roughly 34 million population, the United Nations World Food Programme’s (WFP) sea-freighted cargo dropped 81% year over year (World Food Programme, 2024). These are not isolated incidents. They reveal a failure of world governance in critically shared spaces.

While collective security for land-based conflict was addressed in Chapter VII at the UN’s founding, the same cannot be said of conflict on the remaining 70% of the Earth’s surface. In 1982, the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) codified freedom of navigation as a legal right but created no enforcement mechanism. This may be the Charter’s most consequential and under-appreciated gap. Put simply, freedom of navigation is the fundamental global public good left ungoverned by the UN. The current system of unilateral provision is economically irrational and strategically fragile. At the same time, the technology necessary to enforce freedom of navigation is increasingly more affordable. Therefore, Article 109 should be invoked to add a new chapter to the Charter establishing a multilateral maritime security force.

The current system faces two distinct and interconnected problems.

First, freedom of navigation on the high seas is a classic global public good: one ship’s safe passage does not reduce another’s, and it cannot, by definition, be denied to non-contributors (Ostrom, 1990; Sandler, 2020). This naturally creates a free-rider problem because every trading nation benefits from secure sea lanes whether or not it contributes to their protection, each has an incentive to let others bear the cost. Today, one state provides the overwhelming share of the world’s maritime security: the U.S. Department of the Navy (DON) alone spent $255.8 billion in fiscal year 2024. Historically, Washington’s commitment to global freedom of navigation has been so credible that allies can rationally redirect their own defense spending elsewhere (Feldman & Shipton, 2024). After the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (NATO) 2014 Wales spending pledge, even non-U.S. allies’ naval capabilities declined–a pattern consistent with burden shifting away from maritime assets when U.S. commitment remains credible.

It is only rational for other states to free ride such an under-institutionalized public goods regime. Furthermore, a perverse structure emerges: the better the U.S. Navy is at assuring maritime stability, the less anyone else needs to invest in it. The United States improving actually makes the system more fragile, because the gap between its contribution and everyone else’s widens with every success (Heerman & Wessel, 2025).

The second issue lies in UNCLOS’ enforcement-mechanism-free legal structure. While establishing the legal right of freedom of navigation (FON), enforcement rests entirely on flag state jurisdiction. Flags of convenience—where shipowners register vessels in states like Panama, Liberia, or the Marshall Islands that impose minimal regulation—create what the House of Lords called a “jurisdictional vacuum on the high seas” among states with “no meaningful capacity to enforce regulations” (House of Lords International Relations and Defence Committee, 2022). Its dispute settlement mechanisms are “not applicable to breaches of law carried out by non-state actors” (House of Lords International Relations and Defence Committee, 2022)—exactly the actors, from Houthi missile crews to Somali pirates, that pose persistent threats to shipping. Even when arbitration does apply to state actors, compliance is voluntary: China rejected the 2016 Permanent Court of Arbitration ruling on the South China Sea and continued building military installations on disputed reefs with no enforcement consequence (Permanent Court of Arbitration, 2016).

The clearest illustration of both failures together is the Black Sea Grain Initiative (BSGI). Brokered by the United Nations and Türkiye in July 2022, the BSGI was a diplomatic success. It moved roughly 33 million metric tons of grain to 45 countries in a single year, including 725,000 tons purchased by WFP for Afghanistan, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen. It helped drive the FAO Food Price Index down more than 23 percent from its March 2022 peak (United Nations, 2023). But its Joint Coordination Centre had only voluntary security guarantees. On 18 July 2023, Russia simply walked away. Two days later, it struck Odesa’s port infrastructure, destroying an estimated 60,000 tons of grain. The Security Council could not act against a withdrawing permanent member.History shows that enforceable protection works when it is provided. During the Somali piracy crisis, roughly 90% of WFP food aid to Somalia arrived by sea. When naval escorts began in November 2007, no escorted WFP ship was ever attacked. When escorts lapsed in mid-2008, shippers refused to load WFP cargo for Somalia entirely (UN News, 2008). The lesson is plain: armed maritime protection of humanitarian corridors works, and without it, the corridors collapse.

Ad hoc coalitions of the willing are useful as stopgaps and moral victories, but they remain voluntary, temporary, and are often commanded by a single capital. This is a recurring pattern. They are not a standing public institution for a standing public good. The issue is not that diplomacy fails, but that diplomacy without enforceable maritime security has no base on which to be effective. So what is to be done?

The Charter’s framers expected Article 109’s comprehensive review mechanism to be used relatively early in the organization’s life (Global Governance Forum, 2024; United Nations, 1945). Eighty years on, it has not occurred once. The failure to address the gaps in securing the maritime commons is a fitting candidate for a first review.

A helpful reform may look like a new Charter chapter creating a Maritime Collective Security Organization (UNMCSO). It would have three clear mandates: (1) protect freedom of navigation in designated international chokepoints and sea lines of communication; (2) secure humanitarian maritime corridors when disruption risks mass civilian harm; and (3) provide integrated surveillance, deterrence, and response against maritime coercion by state and non-state actors. Funding would be assessed in proportion to each member’s share of global seaborne trade by volume: durable commons governance requires proportional equivalence between the benefits a member receives and the costs it bears Ostrom (1990). The UNMCSO would operate in two layers.

First, a persistent network of unmanned surface vessels (USVs), aerial drones, and shared maritime domain awareness systems would provide wide-area monitoring, convoy screening, and low-cost interception against asymmetric threats. This is where technological change alters feasibility. Low-cost interceptors have increasingly challenged unfavorable cost-exchange ratios in drone defense, with systems in the low-thousands range engaging attack drones priced an order of magnitude higher (Khan, 2026; Segal, 2026). At the platform level, U.S. congressional planning around the Modular Attack Surface Craft (MASC) program points toward several dozen armed autonomous vessels as a credible force concept, while conventional frigates remain billion dollar platforms (Congressional Budget Office, 2020; Congressional Research Service, 2026). These autonomous systems don’t replace navies, but they dramatically reduce the fixed cost of presence.

Second, an international, rotating conventional-deterrent fleet of frigates and destroyers contributed by member states, modeled directly on UN peacekeeping troop contributions, would provide credible deterrent presence at major chokepoints such as Malacca, Hormuz, and Bab el-Mandeb. Command would rotate among contributing regions rather than resting permanently with one state, unlike the U.S.-commanded Combined Maritime Forces (CMF).

Evidence that this model works comes from the field: Ukraine reopened its own grain corridor unilaterally, using naval drones for sea denial rather than escort. Relatively low-cost Ukrainian uncrewed systems helped force a much larger fleet into a defensive posture and retreat key assets away from contested waters (Raveendran, 2025; Sutton, 2024). In the assessment of the Royal United Services Institute, this force pushed the Russian fleet back toward Novorossiysk and, “denied Russia sea control” over the western Black Sea (Sutton, 2024). By December 2023, Ukraine was exporting 4.8 million metric tons of grain per month, exceeding the BSGI’s own peak volume, without any diplomatic concession from Moscow. The drones did not escort grain ships. Instead, they removed Russia’s capacity to threaten the corridor, and that removal of threat persuaded insurers and shippers to use the route again. This is credible enforcement that functions independent of the adversary’s cooperation, and such capacity is now affordable to more states at war, not only to a superpower.

Ratification would be no easy feat. Any Charter amendment under Article 109 requires approval by two-thirds of UN member states, including all five permanent members of the Security Council (United Nations, 1945). But every P5 member is a major maritime trading nation with a direct stake in stable sea lanes, and burden-sharing reduces what each of them, including the United States, must spend unilaterally. Additionally, some will ask whether autonomous systems can be trusted with enforcement authority. The EU’s COLOSSUS project, a Horizon Europe initiative building unmanned swarm patrol systems for port security (European Commission, 2025), and the deployment of Ukrainian-designed STING interceptors at the U.S. Central Command’s (CENTCOM) Prince Sultan Air Base (Khan, 2026) demonstrate that these technologies already operate within existing legal and command structures.

By trade-assessing and rotating command, UNMCSO would be far more democratic than the status quo, in which one state’s domestic politics largely decide whether the global commons remains open. Nations disproportionately dependent on seaborne imports and disproportionately harmed by shipping disruptions currently have no voice in maritime security decisions made almost entirely in Washington (UNCTAD, 2024). Trade-proportional funding lets smaller nations contribute in proportion to their stake while still holding formal governance standing.

The causal chain has already been demonstrated twice across generations. In Feyrer’s historical natural experiment, chokepoint closure reduced trade and then income (Feyrer, 2009). In current crises, maritime disruption increases logistics costs, raises consumer prices, and degrades humanitarian delivery (Defense Intelligence Agency, 2024; UNCTAD, 2024; World Food Programme, 2024; Yusuf, 2024). The status quo responds with legal rights that lack executors, diplomacy that lacks enforcement, and burden sharing that relies on voluntary restraint of free-rider incentives.

In that light, Charter reform is not institutional ambition for institutional ambition’s sake—it is a needed correction. If convened, an Article 109 General Conference should consider a new chapter establishing an institution like the one explored in this paper: a standing, trade-proportionally funded, democratically governed maritime collective security institution built on cooperation and the force asymmetries enabled by technology. The mechanism exists and the technology exists. The only variable remaining is political will.

References

Congressional Budget Office. (2020). The cost of the Navy’ s new frigate. Congressional Budget Office. https://www.cbo.gov/publication/56675

Congressional Research Service. (2026). Navy large unmanned surface vessels (USVs): Background and issues for Congress (No. R45757). Congressional Research Service. https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R45757

Defense Intelligence Agency. (2024). Yemen: Houthi attacks placing pressure on international trade. Defense Intelligence Agency. https://www.dia.mil/Portals/110/Images/News/Military_Powers_Publications/YEM_Houthi-Attacks-Pressuring-International-Trade.pdf

European Commission. (2025). COLOSSUS: Multi-purpose unmanned vehicle swarm patrol intelligence platform for port security and resilience (Project 101225980). European Commission, CORDIS. https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/101225980

Feldman, N., & Shipton, M. (2024). Gunboats and butter: The two percent guideline and NATO burden shifting in the maritime domain. Contemporary Security Policy. https://doi.org/10.1080/13523260.2024.2343637

Feyrer, J. (2009). Distance, trade, and income: The 1967 to 1975 closing of the Suez Canal as a natural experiment. NBER Working Papers, (15557). https://doi.org/10.3386/w15557

Global Governance Forum. (2024). Article 109, for a renewed UN Charter. https://globalgovernanceforum.org/un-charter-reform-coalition/

Heerman, K., & Wessel, D. (2025). Chokepoints and coercion: Iran’ s challenge to maritime openness. Brookings Institution. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/chokepoints-and-coercion-irans-challenge-to-maritime-openness/

House of Lords International Relations and Defence Committee. (2022). UNCLOS: The law of the sea in the 21st century (HL Paper 159). House of Lords. https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/9005/documents/159002/default

Khan, B. (2026). Shahed drone: Iran’ s attrition weapon and the 2026 cost crisis. Quwa. https://quwa.org/iran/military-news-iran/shahed-drone-irans-attrition-weapon-and-the-cost-exchange-crisis-of-2026/

Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press.

Permanent Court of Arbitration. (2016). The South China Sea arbitration (The Republic of the Philippines v. The People’ s Republic of China) (Case No. 2013-19). Permanent Court of Arbitration. https://pca-cpa.org/en/cases/7/

Raveendran, S. (2025). Sea denial: The Ukrainian case study and the future of naval warfare. Journal of Strategic Security, 18 (4). https://doi.org/10.5038/1944-0472.18.4.2564

Sandler, T. (2020). Global public goods: A survey. Journal of Economic Literature, 58 (3), 648–680. https://doi.org/10.1257/jel.20191546

Segal, J. (2026). Better late than never, US and allies race toward Ukrainian counter-Shahed tech. Foreign Policy Research Institute. https://www.fpri.org/article/2026/03/better-late-than-never-us-and-allies-race-toward-ukrainian-counter-shahed-tech/

Sutton, H. I. (2024, August 20). Uncrewed platforms have been critical to Ukraine’ s success in the Black Sea. Royal United Services Institute. https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/uncrewed-platforms-have-been-critical-ukraines-success-black-sea

UN News. (2008, August 6). UN hails Canada’ s decision to provide escorts for food ships heading to Somalia. https://news.un.org/en/story/2008/08/268492

UNCTAD. (2018). 50 years of review of maritime transport, 1968–2018: Reflecting on the past, exploring the future. United Nations Conference on Trade; Development. https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/dtl2018d1_en.pdf

UNCTAD. (2024). Review of maritime transport 2024 . United Nations Conference on Trade; Development. https://unctad.org/publication/review-maritime-transport-2024

United Nations. (1945). Charter of the United Nations. https://www.un.org/en/about-us/un-charter/full-text

United Nations. (2023). The Black Sea Grain Initiative: What was achieved? Why was it important? https://www.un.org/en/black-sea-grain-initiative/achievements

World Food Programme. (2024). Yemen annual country report 2024. United Nations World Food Programme. https://reliefweb.int/attachments/bd15b9d7-efcc-472c-ab20-bd1eb2f8bb27/WFP%20Yemen%20-%20Annual%20Country%20Report%202024%20-%20Full%20Report%20%28English%29.pdf

Yusuf, M. (2024). IRC suspends Red Sea route for Sudan aid amid rising cost, risks. Voice of America. https://www.voanews.com/a/irc-suspends-red-sea-route-for-sudan-aid-amid-rising-cost-risks/7506761.html

The Rulers of the Nuclear Powers are Slow Learners

The Rulers of the Nuclear Powers are Slow Learners

Although 81 years have passed since the atomic bombing of Japan in August 1945, the rulers of major nations continue their reckless march toward nuclear annihilation.

The nine nuclear powers (the United States, Russia, China, Britain, France, Israel, India, Pakistan, and North Korea), possessing some 12,100 nuclear warheads, are all busily upgrading and expanding their nuclear weapons arsenals at an accelerating pace.  Nuclear weapons spending rose to an all-time high of $119 billion in 2025―a 19 percent increase over the preceding year.  The U.S. government alone, which accounted for more than half of this spending, is embarked on a $1.7 trillion, decades-long nuclear weapons buildup.

As the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN) has observed, “this overwhelming spending on nuclear weapons shows a willingness to research, develop, finance and build tools to exterminate humanity.”

Moreover, international nuclear arms control and disarmament agreements among the nuclear powers have collapsed.  Russia and the United States own 86 percent of the world’s nuclear weapons and, although they signed numerous treaties in the past to limit or reduce the size of their nuclear arsenals, the last of these treaties, New START, expired this February.

The accelerating nuclear arms race is accompanied by repeated threats of nuclear war.  Russian officials are particularly notorious in this connection.  According to the Voice of America, from early 2022 to late 2024 Russian officials publicly issued 135 nuclear threats, with 27 of them coming from Vladimir Putin.  But America’s Donald Trump has also publicly and repeatedly threatened other countries with nuclear destruction, as has North Korea’s Kim Jong Un.

Early this year, the editors of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, assessing this deteriorating situation, moved the hands of their famous “Doomsday Clock” to 85 seconds to midnight, the most dangerous setting in its history.

Of course, there have been a great many warnings that nuclear weapons portend global disaster, including many beginning right after the shocking annihilation of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.  “Seldom, if ever,” reported CBS radio commentator Edward R. Murrow, “has war ended leaving the victors . . . with such a realization that . . . survival is not assured.”  The Chicago Tribune warned that a future atomic war would leave the world “a barren waste, in which the survivors . . . will hide in caves.”  In France, the resistance leader Albert Camus declared that the modern world had “reached the last degree of savagery,” in which nations were faced with the prospect of “collective suicide.”

As nuclear fear swept around the world, large numbers of people sought to avert catastrophe.  Some called for dramatically strengthened global governance to prevent the outbreak of nuclear war, while others, with the same goal in mind, championed nuclear disarmament.  Speaking on behalf of the newly-formed Emergency Committee of Atomic Scientists, Albert Einstein typified this popular uprising by arguing that “a new type of thinking is essential if mankind is to survive.”

Over subsequent decades, the antinuclear movement ebbed and flowed, but, at times of mass mobilization, it had an important effect on nuclear weapons policies.  Naturally, the leaders of many nations felt the allure of nuclear weapons, especially after thousands of years of human history in which national security often seemed to rest upon military strength.  Nevertheless, as indicated by opinion polls and massive demonstrations, antinuclear agitation inspired revulsion against nuclear weapons and nuclear war among large portions of the public.  Consequently, most governments decided not to build nuclear weapons or even to deploy them on their territory.  

Hard-pressed by antinuclear campaigners and public opinion, even the small number of governments that built nuclear weapons found themselves unable to resist agreement on nuclear arms control and disarmament measures.  Dwight Eisenhower, John F. Kennedy, Nikita Khrushchev, Ronald Reagan, and George H.W. Bush were not nuclear “doves” when they entered office, but, in response to popular pressure, they took significant action to curb nuclear dangers.  Some government officials, like Mikhail Gorbachev, even became fervent converts to the antinuclear cause.

As the 20th century came to an end, however, progress in rolling back the nuclear menace began to unravel.  Popular protest declined, and nuclear disarmament organizations dwindled in size.  By contrast, conservative and militarist forces grew more assertive, blocking U.S. Senate ratification of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, demanding the building of new nuclear weapons, and derailing Barack Obama’s initiative for creating a nuclear weapons-free world.

Although nuclear disarmament organizations were on the defensive during the early 21st century, they retained enough strength to produce one major victory.  Joining together in the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons, they cooperated closely with officials in small, non-nuclear nations to produce a series of UN conferences on nuclear issues.  Then, at the 2017 conference, the national delegates voted 122 to 1 to adopt the UN Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), which banned nuclear weapons.  Entering into force in January 2021, the treaty has been signed, thus far, by 100 countries―a majority of the world’s nations.

Even so, the situation remains dire.  Today, most rulers of the nuclear powers are nationalistic, militaristic, and authoritarian.  Faced with a world plagued by international conflict, they show no interest in strengthening global governance or even in securing nuclear arms control and disarmament.  Instead, they are busy arming their nations for war, including a disastrous nuclear war.  Not surprisingly, none of them is willing to sign or even abide by the TPNW.  Although the antinuclear movement continues to oppose their priorities, it remains weak and unable to halt the momentum toward nuclear catastrophe.

Thus, unless there is an advent of new, less hawkish rulers, a movement revival, or both, a nuclear war seems likely.

Admittedly, it’s possible that, when a calamitous nuclear war does occur, it will finally convince even the slow learners among government officials that the nuclear age requires new thinking about international relations.  Unfortunately, that recognition will arrive too late to matter, for such a war will snuff out most life on earth.

CGS Fellows Take Youth-Led Research to the UN High-Level Political Forum

CGS Fellows Take Youth-Led Research to the UN High-Level Political Forum

The 2026 United Nations High-Level Political Forum brings together governments, civil society organizations, and changemakers from around the world to advance progress toward the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Among those contributing to the global conversations were two fellows from Citizens for Global Solutions’ (CGS) Global Governance Fellowship, who were invited by Green Hope Foundation Founder and President, Kehkashan Basu, M.S.M., MBA to serve as keynote speakers during United Nations parallel side events at the UN Headquarters in New York.

Building on their previous experience as keynote speakers during the 70th session of the Commission on the Status of Women (CSW70) parallel side events, the fellows returned to the United Nations to share their research. Their participation emphasized the growing recognition that young people are essential partners in shaping solutions to today’s most pressing global challenges.

Samara Husain (far left) speaking as a keynote speaker and Kehkahshan Basu (far right) as moderator, founder and President of Green Hope Foundation.
Samara Husain (far left) speaking as a keynote speaker and Kehkahshan Basu (far right) as moderator, founder and President of Green Hope Foundation.

Samara Husain is a senior nursing student at Trinity Washington University who is currently completing her externship at the Surgical Oncology Unit at MedStar Washington Hospital Center and an Alumni Fellow of the Global Governance Fellowship ‘26. As a keynote speaker, Samara brought a public health perspective to the conversation, demonstrating how housing is not only an urban planning issue but also one of the most important factors of health. Safe housing, clean environments, reliable water and sanitation, and accessible healthcare are all essential components of healthy communities. By reframing housing as a public health issue, Samara showcased the connection between SDG 11, Sustainable Cities and Communities, and SDG 3, Good Health and Well-Being.

Anastasia Tomlinson presenting her research as keynote speaker.
Anastasia Tomlinson presenting her research as keynote speaker.

Anastasia Tomlinson is a junior majoring in Politics and Policy and minoring in Public Health at Trinity Washington University, an advocate for nuclear disarmament and Alumni Fellow for the Global Governance Fellowship ‘26 cohort. Expanding her research on health, housing, and gender in Brazil, Anastasia focused on SDG indicator 9.1.1, which measures the number of rural people who live within 2 km of an all-season road. Anastasia detailed the gaps between this indicator’s reported data and the reality for the people living in Brazil. She highlighted the importance of accessible healthcare, specifically hospital access, and how not considering infrastructure from public health (SDG 3) and gendered (SDG 5) standpoints inhibits inclusive progress for rural women.

Samara and Anastasia’s presentation highlighted the power of grassroots initiatives and demonstrated how collaboration between youth leaders and community-based organizations can drive meaningful change. Through partnerships with organizations such as Green Hope Foundation and ImpulsoGov young advocates are helping bring grassroots solutions into global policy conversations.

One of the most impactful aspects of the discussion was its multifaceted approach, with each panelist contributing a unique perspective shaped by their expertise and lived experiences. The conversation explored both the tangible foundations of sustainable communities, such as housing, transportation, healthcare, and public infrastructure, and the equally important social infrastructure that creates a sense of belonging, trust, and community. As Samara reflected, sustainable development is “both about the spaces we build and also about the relationships, systems, and opportunities that enable people to thrive within them.”

Anastasia Tomlinson and Samara Husain pose in front of the UN flag at the United Nations Headquarters in New York.
Anastasia Tomlinson and Samara Husain pose in front of the UN flag at the United Nations Headquarters in New York.

The greatest takeaway from the panel was recognizing just how interconnected the Sustainable Development Goals truly are. The SDGs do not exist in silos, progress in one area depends on collaboration across many others. The intergenerational dialogue among the panelists was mirrored by an equally diverse audience, and the thoughtful questions that followed enriched the conversation with both fresh perspectives and the wisdom of lived experience. This exchange demonstrated how meaningful solutions emerge when people from different backgrounds, generations, and disciplines come together to learn from one another.
__

This article was first shared with subscribers of CGS Field Notes, our LinkedIn newsletter featuring insights, updates, and analysis on global governance from Citizens for Global Solutions. Subscribe on LinkedIn to get future stories like this one delivered straight to your feed.

Call for Papers: Mondial Special Edition on Rewriting the UN Charter

Call for Papers: Mondial Special Edition on Rewriting the UN Charter

Pandemics, nuclear risk, unmanaged AI, unpayable sovereign debt, and a destabilizing climate have one thing in common: no country can solve them alone. The institution built to coordinate that work was designed in 1945 and has never been fundamentally updated since.

Citizens for Global Solutions and World Federalist Movement-Canada are now inviting proposals for a special edition of Mondial: An International Journal of World Federalists, devoted to what an upgraded UN Charter could deliver for humanity across a wide range of policy areas.

Read the full call: Call for Papers, Mondial Special Edition on Article 109 (PDF)

Why this edition, and why now

The delegates who met in San Francisco knew they were writing a starting point, not a finished document. Truman said at the signing that the Charter would “be expanded and improved as time goes on.” They wrote that expectation directly into the text. Article 109 is the built-in mechanism by which each generation can revisit, revise, and remake the UN to meet the challenges of its own time.

Eight decades on, the gap between what the world needs from the UN and what the 1945 architecture was designed to deliver keeps widening. From the risks posed by nuclear and biological weapons, AI, and ecosystem collapse, to pandemic response, the Sustainable Development Goals, unsustainable sovereign debt, and unaddressed historical injustice, the present structure of the UN has too often blocked meaningful progress across exactly the domains where cooperation matters most.

What the special edition asks

This edition asks contributors to set aside the politics and structural limitations of today, to dream big, and to make the case for what a rewritten Charter could unlock in their own field. Three questions anchor every submission:

  • What could rewriting the UN Charter unlock in your area of international policy expertise?
  • What policies would you like to see an upgraded United Nations adopt and implement that have not been achievable or enforceable through existing treaty processes, voluntary pledges, or piecemeal reforms?
  • How would those policy changes improve the lives of people across the globe, improve our collective ability to handle the challenges we face, or help lead to a more peaceful, just, and sustainable future?

Proposed topics

The editors welcome submissions on any of the tracks below. This is a partial list, and proposals from any subject area or perspective are welcome.

  • Planetary boundaries and improving climate governance. What Charter review could do for the global commons that the Paris Accords and the COP process cannot, including a Global Commons Trusteeship, a Climate Council with binding authority, legal rights for nature, or planetary boundary indicators embedded in UN governance.
  • Existential and catastrophic risk management, disarmament. Regulation of artificial intelligence, nuclear weapons and disarmament, biosecurity, asteroid defense, and ecosystem collapse.
  • Historical injustice and reparations. UN reform as part of a broader process of historical repair, and as a way to correct the structural inequities embedded in post-1945 institutions.
  • Peace, security, and Security Council reform. What a functioning, reimagined Security Council could do to prevent genocide, end wars, and build positive peace, including options for ending impunity and for reforming or overriding the veto.
  • Why Charter review is in the P5’s interest. What enlightened self-interest looks like for major powers in the 21st century, and how weighted voting, General Assembly revitalization, or a redesign of Council mechanics could break the gridlock the P5 themselves bemoan.
  • Advancing equitable solutions for finance and development. The relationship between the UN and the international financial architecture, including standardized rates and risk premiums, centralized funding mechanisms, and restructuring unsustainable debt.
  • Global economic stabilization. Predictable rather than capricious tariff rules, guaranteed rights of navigation, a global UN-backed currency, and independent UN financing.
  • Global health and pandemic preparedness. Equitable access to medicines and vaccines, disease eradication, global health financing, unrestricted humanitarian access, and improved emergency coordination.
  • The SDGs, the Pact for the Future, and the post-2030 agenda. What comes after the SDG framework expires in 2030, and how Charter review could serve as a cross-cutting acceleration process.

Format

Articles run 700 to 2000 words and are allocated two to four large format magazine pages. The strongest submissions identify a specific structural flaw in the Charter or the wider global governance system, describe the state behavior and tensions that flow from it, and then devote the bulk of the piece to the proposed solution and how it resolves those tensions.

Mondial follows the AP Style Guide and is written for an educated, globally engaged audience. Scholarly depth is welcome. Unnecessary jargon is not.

How to submit

Send expressions of interest or first drafts to the editor, Dr. Justin Haner, at [email protected]. Submissions should include:

  1. A working title, and the thematic track it most closely aligns with, if applicable.
  2. Either a summary of the proposed article or a full first draft of 700 to 2000 words.
  3. A brief bio of the author, or a link to one.

Expressions of interest are due by October 15, 2026. First drafts are due by October 30, 2026. The target publication date is March 2027.

Proposals must be submitted in English, though the editors are glad to work with and provide editorial support for authors whose first language is not English.

An invitation, not just a legal mechanism

At its best, Article 109 is much more than a clause in a treaty. It is an invitation to ask, with seriousness and imagination, what kind of United Nations humanity now requires. Mondial invites contributors to help answer that question.

Download the full call for papers (PDF) or browse past issues of Mondial.

A Dream Deferred, But Still Alive

A Dream Deferred, But Still Alive

On March 1, 1945, only six weeks before his death, U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt delivered an address to Congress that pointed toward a sweeping transformation of international relations.

With the Axis powers tottering toward defeat in World War II, Roosevelt reported that the recently concluded Yalta conference of Allied leaders had agreed upon “a common ground for peace.”  It would “spell the end of the system of unilateral action, the exclusive alliances, the spheres of influence, the balances of power, and all the other expedients that have been tried for centuries―and have always failed.”  These approaches would be replaced by “a universal organization,” a “permanent structure of peace upon which we can begin to build . . . that better world in which our children and grandchildren . . . must live, and can live.”

As a follow-up, delegates from fifty nations met in San Francisco from April 25 to June 26, 1945 and drafted the United Nations Charter.  Although the Charter affirmed “faith in fundamental human rights, in the dignity and worth of the human person, in the equal rights of men and women and of nations large and small” and promised to promote “justice,” “social progress,” and “better standards of life in larger freedom,” its first proclaimed goal (and top priority) was “to save succeeding generations from the scourge of war.”

In subsequent decades, the United Nations did an effective job of encouraging human rights and social progress.  The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which Eleanor Roosevelt occupied a pivotal role in creating, drafting, and seeing through to unanimous adoption, represented a substantial advance in social, cultural, and economic rights.  In addition, the United Nations played an essential part in the widespread decolonization process in Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean, in promoting economic development and public health in impoverished nations, and in developing international agreements to address environmental issues.

Ironically, however, when it came to preventing military aggression and war, the UN record was less impressive.  Yes, the international organization successfully mediated more than 170 peace settlements, deployed over 70 peacekeeping missions to stabilize post-conflict zones, and fostered important measures for arms control and disarmament.  Nevertheless, more than 285 military conflicts have erupted around the world in the years since 1945, taking a vast human and economic toll.  Furthermore, the number of wars between nations has increased sharply over the past decade, reaching, in 2025, the highest level since World War II.

If the United Nations has fallen short of its goal of ending war, this is largely due to the behavior of the “great powers.”  The United States, the Soviet Union (and its successor, Russia), France, Britain, and China have employed their veto at least 320 times in the UN Security Council to frustrate UN action.  They have also been leading participants in some of the world’s most disastrous wars fought since 1945―in Korea, Hungary, Vietnam, Algeria, Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Ukraine, and numerous other nations.

With the United Nations frequently hobbled by the most powerful nations, the defense of peace has often been left to citizen activism, especially the peace movement.  And, indeed, that movement has managed to stir up popular opposition to militarism, occasionally succeeding in bringing wars to an end.  Working with its natural allies among smaller nations and at the United Nations, the peace movement has been particularly successful at generating nuclear arms control and disarmament measures.

Sometimes the movement even made converts among the leaders of the major powers.  Soviet party leader Mikhail Gorbachev, the key government official who brought the Cold War to an end, credited much of his “New Thinking” to the nuclear disarmament activism of his time.  In a remarkable address, delivered on December 7, 1988, Gorbachev told the United Nations that “the use or threat of force no longer can . . . be an instrument of foreign policy.”  In their place, he said, the world needed the establishment of a strong international security system, under the direction of a revitalized United Nations.  It was time “put an end to an era of wars, confrontation and regional conflicts,” he said.  “This is our common goal, and we can only reach it together.”

Although Gorbachev was swept from power thanks to the dissolution of the Soviet Union, another government official, Barack Obama, took up his role.  Deeply influenced when still a student by the nuclear disarmament movement of the 1980s, Obama, during his 2008 presidential campaign, promised to seek “the peace of a world without nuclear weapons.”  After his election as President of the United States, he followed through by chairing a dramatic meeting of the UN Security Council―only the fifth in the Council’s history held at the level of heads of state―that proclaimed a commitment to the goal of a world free of nuclear weapons.  UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon termed it “an historic event.”

But the end of the Cold War provided the best opportunity for a decisive turn toward peace, and that opportunity had already passed.  Neither Gorbachev’s successors nor Congressional Republicans could stomach Obama’s proposal, which sank amid a rising tide of rightwing nationalism.  New government leaders like Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Benjamin Netanyahu took power, assailing the United Nations and embarking on programs of weapons buildups, unilateral action, and wars.

Even so, the books have not been closed on the future.  As opinion polls reveal, public support for heightened global cooperation is widespread, as is public disdain for military invasions and occupations of other lands.  The smaller nations of the world are revolting against the major military powers, as revealed by overwhelming votes at the United Nations to condemn great power military aggression and to implement the UN Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons―now ratified by more than half the world’s countries.  Recently, in fact, an international campaign has begun to strengthen the United Nations by amending its Charter.

The dream has been deferred, but it remains alive.

Welcome Sovaida Ma’ani Ewing to the CGS National Advisory Council

Welcome Sovaida Ma’ani Ewing to the CGS National Advisory Council

Citizens for Global Solutions (CGS) is pleased to welcome Sovaida Ma’ani Ewing to its National Advisory Council (NAC), bringing to the organization decades of experience in international law, global governance, peacebuilding, and ethics-based institutional design.

A barrister-at-law of England and Wales and an attorney-at-law in the United States, Sovaida holds an LLM in International Law and European Union Law from Cambridge University. Her distinguished legal career has included private practice in Washington, D.C., including her own law firm, service as an adjunct professor of law, and work as an attorney-advisor in the Legal Adviser’s Office of the U.S. Department of State.

For the past sixteen years, Sovaida has been serving as the Founder and Director of the Center for Peace and Global Governance (CPGG), a think tank and educational platform dedicated to developing principled solutions to some of the world’s most pressing challenges, including climate change, energy security, peace and security, arms control, resource equity, and global institutional reform. Through publications, podcasts, lectures, workshops, and strategic consulting, CPGG advances conversations and contributes to thinking about how ethical principles can inform and shape effective governance at every level. Sovaida is host of a popular audio and video podcast “Reimagining Our World,” which is dedicated to creating a vision of the world we want and infusing hope that we can make the choices necessary to attain it. It is available on most podcast platforms and video form on the CPGG YouTube channel,

Sovaida’s work has also played an important role in shaping CGS’s Global Governance Fellowship at Trinity Washington University, where she has served as a featured facilitator since the program’s pilot in 2022. Her workshops challenge students to imagine how ethical principles can be translated into practical institutional structures capable of addressing complex global challenges. Through exercises focused on a hypothetical Global Energy Authority and a principle-driven system of collective security, students learn that governance is not simply about power; it is about designing institutions that embody justice, accountability, cooperation, and shared responsibility.

As she joins CGS’s National Advisory Council, we sat down with Sovaida to discuss the future of ethics-based global governance and the role emerging leaders can play in building more peaceful, equitable, effective, and resilient systems.

In your view, what role can ethical principles play in advancing the long-term vision of democratic world federation, and what strategies are most effective for translating that vision into political reality?

I believe that a shared set of foundational principles or global ethics is an indispensable foundation for the establishment of a viable system of global governance—ideally in the form of a democratically elected world federation of nation-states. It behooves the international community to bend every effort to identify these principles and agree upon them. Having done that, they must be uncompromisingly operationalized in two ways: firstly, as a starting point when addressing any global challenge; and secondly, as the unshakeable basis upon which we design and build global institutions and their processes.

Two examples of such principles that should be incorporated into a new 21st-century-ready system of international relations are: firstly, the principle that all nations deserve to be treated with equal regard; and secondly, that the advantage of one nation (the part) can only be assured by guaranteeing the advantage of all nations (the whole).

Applying these two principles alone will yield solutions to the plethora of global challenges that plague us while ensuring that these solutions are congruent with each other (rather than undermining each other, as they often do today), proactive and informed by a long-term view, and considerate of the collective interest of humanity rather than narrow nationalistic or individual interests.

In this way, we can avoid the pitfall we so often fall into of reaching for expedient, short-term, and reactive solutions that cater to a narrow set of interests and not only fail to solve the original problem but also sow the seeds of the next disaster.

So, whether we’re considering the challenge of revamping the nuclear non-proliferation regime or whether we should continue to allow a limited number of nation-states to wield veto power in the Security Council, the way forward becomes clear. In the former instance, it becomes apparent that treating nations even-handedly requires the creation of a system in which all nations participate and which binds them all, with no opt-outs. Moreover, if any nation flouts the rules, the consequences should apply to all equally, whether we view the country as an ally or an enemy, as trustworthy or not. With respect to the question of the veto in the Security Council, it quickly becomes apparent that affording nations any sort of veto is antithetical to the claim that nation-states should be treated equally.

The strategy I would recommend for nations to identify and unitedly agree upon a set of global ethics is the one I proposed in my book, “Building a World Federation: The Key to Resolving Our Global Crises.” Essentially, I suggest we follow the roadmap created by the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (established by the Canadian government in 2001) in crafting the principle of the Responsibility to Protect, which was ultimately unanimously endorsed by all 192 nation-states at the World Summit in New York in 2005. This principle is considered an emerging norm in international practice, while some would even argue that it has become part of customary international law.

How do you envision students and emerging leaders contributing to the development of a Global Energy Authority or a principle-driven system of collective security?

Students and emerging leaders can contribute to a principle-driven system of collective security by recognizing certain realities: in today’s interconnected and interdependent world, wars are no longer local or regional in their impact but rather have the capacity to trigger global crises.

Take the civil war in Syria. It led to a refugee crisis that impacted not only neighboring states like Jordan, Lebanon, and Turkey but also regions farther afield, particularly Europe. The waves of refugees arriving in Europe contributed to a rise in far-right populist movements and, some would argue, were a main trigger for Brexit. The conflict also created fertile ground for ISIL to take root, with devastating and bloody consequences for many.

Meanwhile, the war in Ukraine spawned a global food crisis, a global energy crisis, and a resurgence of the global nuclear threat to its highest level since the Cuban Missile Crisis. The war with Iran has, similarly, set in motion multiple global crises, including dangerous worldwide inflation that threatens to pull the world into a global economic recession.

We must also recognize the fact that most nations of the world feel insecure. It is this feeling of insecurity that leads them to amass arms and seek weapons of mass destruction, which they misguidedly believe will keep them safe from aggression. The ensuing arms race and proliferation of weapons, including nuclear weapons, pose a huge danger to the world as a whole.

It is clear that the path we are on is untenable and will only lead to increased suffering and self-destruction. The time has come for the international community to come together and collaboratively craft a system of collective security that ensures that all nations are secure. They must recognize that, in a world as interconnected and interdependent as ours, a collective challenge of this order demands a collective solution.

The days of unilateral responses or the creation of ad hoc coalitions to respond to threats are over. The collective solution we need requires that all nations collaborate and participate in the creation of a global system of collective security in which they each contribute troops and arms to an international police force that will act at the behest of a democratically elected World Parliament, in the collective interests of humanity, and in accordance with predetermined and collectively agreed-upon rules and guidelines.

In the spirit of operationalizing the principles of oneness and equality, all nations must participate. There can be no opt-outs, and there must be a binding agreement among all nations that, if one nation were to breach or threaten the peace, all nations would arise to bring it to heel using the mechanism of the global standing force.

Having understood that this system is indispensable to ensuring the peace of the world, these students and emerging leaders would strive to raise awareness of this 21st-century-ready idea in all their spheres of endeavor, work, and social discourse, with the goal of spreading this idea to such a degree that we will eventually elect the kinds of leaders who have the requisite sense of responsibility to create the sort of principle-driven system of collective security that constitutes the indispensable foundation for a peaceful world.

Looking Forward

Sovaida Ma’ani Ewing’s appointment to the CGS National Advisory Council reflects CGS’s commitment to engaging thought leaders who bring both deep expertise and innovative perspectives to the challenges shaping our world.

At a time when global issues increasingly demand collaborative solutions, her work offers a compelling reminder that ethical principles are not abstract ideals but practical foundations for effective governance. Through her leadership, scholarship, and commitment to mentoring future changemakers, Sovaida continues to inspire a new generation to think boldly about how institutions can be designed to advance peace, justice, sustainability, and human flourishing.

 Sovaida has published five books in the area of peace and global governance including “Building a World Federation: The Key to Resolving our Global Crises.”  “Bridge to Global Governance: Tackling Climate Change, Energy Distribution, and Nuclear Proliferation” and “Collective Security Within Reach.” Her latest book, available on Amazon, is “The Alchemy of Peace: 6 Essential Shifts in Mindsets and Habits to Achieve World Peace.” She also hosts a popular monthly podcast – Reimagining Our World – available on most podcast platforms and on the CPGG YouTube channel that is dedicated to creating a vision of the world we want and infusing hope that we can make the choices necessary to attain it. Sovaida is also a certified mediator and a life mastery coach.  

We are honored to welcome her to the CGS National Advisory Council and look forward to the insights and leadership she will bring to our community. Citizens for Global Solutions has worked for democratic, accountable global cooperation for seventy-nine years. Subscribe to follow our work.

__

This article was first shared with subscribers of CGS Field Notes, our LinkedIn newsletter featuring insights, updates, and analysis on global governance from Citizens for Global Solutions. Subscribe on LinkedIn to get future stories like this one delivered straight to your feed.

The United Nations Charter turned 81 this week.  The world is finally moving to update it.

The United Nations Charter turned 81 this week.  The world is finally moving to update it.

In 2025, the world experienced the highest number of armed conflicts since World War II, and, in a time when many struggle to make ends meet, governments collectively spent a record $2.9 trillion on their militaries. The UN’s Security Council was charged with the maintenance of international peace and security eight decades ago, yet has little to show for it because of a promise made but never kept.

The “San Francisco promise” was the compromise that held the Charter negotiations together. Of the 50 countries present, five of them—the United States, Russia, China, France, and the United Kingdom—secured permanent seats, voting rights, and special veto power for themselves on the Security Council, the UN’s highest governing body. Smaller and middle powers objected fiercely to this proposal by the “P5”, which directly contradicted the Charter’s principle of sovereign equality and relegated them to the indignity of second-class status they continue to endure to this day.

Even the US opposed the absolute veto, conceding it only as the Soviet Union’s price for joining the UN. Many delegates feared, rightly, that allowing one country to block the world’s will would hamstring the organization. We still pay that price today, as two P5 members continue to wage illegal wars and wield their veto as a “get out of jail, free” card to shield themselves and their allies from consequences others would face.

So a bargain was struck. Delegates would sign the Charter, accepting its faults only temporarily and on the condition that within ten years a review conference would be held to revisit the debate. As US delegate John Foster Dulles acknowledged it had “only been possible to secure acceptance of the Charter at San Francisco by a provision assuring that there would be an opportunity to review itin the light of experience”.

Not content to take them at their word, the smaller powers wrote this compromise directly into the Charter as Article 109. It allows a review conference to be convened by a two-thirds vote of the General Assembly and any nine Security Council Members. Critically, the P5 cannot veto the review, nor use the veto during its proceedings. All 193 Member States would participate on strictly equal footing, with each having the same “one vote in the conference,” regardless of size, wealth, or military might.

Yet instead of ten years, 81 have passed. The political will to convene the conference never materialized. What was accepted as a temporary compromise has hardened into a permanent hierarchy. Promises made became promises broken.

Until now.

Bolstered by reform commitments at the 2024 Summit of the Future and the launch of the Article 109 Coalition, a growing cohort is reclaiming the spirit of San Francisco. In just the last six weeks, Romania called for invoking Article 109 at the General Assembly, India discussed the mandate for Charter review at the Security Council, and Andorra asked Security Council candidates if it was time to “revise the Charter and try to see what can we do differently?” None of which ruled it out and Germany remarked “There’s an initiative on it [Article 109] that is interesting, we should think about that.” Kyrgyzstan’s President Zhaparov has told his diplomats to “begin considering possible amendments and proposals now,” promising to table them in September.

The momentum is building. Last September, Kazakh President Tokayev stated that now is the time to have a “serious conversation about UN Charter review.” Kazakhstan and The Gambia officially endorsed Article 109 at that meeting, during which 148 countries, representing 78% of the UN’s Membership, called for the UN to be reformed. Brazil, India, and South Africa have also jointly urged “the convening of a review conference, in accordance with its Article 109”.

Detractors insist a review will never happen because it isn’t in the P5’s interest. But that misreads both the Charter and the mood of the world. As Cameroonian Ambassador Ewumbue-Monono noted last year “Article 109 provides a vital pathway… one that is not subject to veto”. While the P5 would still have to ratify an amended Charter, as Türkiye’s President Erdoğan often says, “the world is bigger than five,” and the global majority grows tired of waiting for permission to live in peace and be treated as equals.

81 years is enough. Ours must be the generation that comes together through the Article 109 process, updates the UN for the 21st century, and reignites the spirit of San Francisco by fulfilling its promise.

From National Independence to Global Interdependence

From National Independence to Global Interdependence

As Americans and people of other former colonies recognize, there’s a great deal to be said for national independence.

But, at times, we might also wonder:  is it sufficient?

Until recently in human history, imperialism was widespread.  In 1939, Britain’s Empire and Commonwealth alone had direct or de facto political and economic control of 25 percent of the world’s population and 30 percent of its land mass.  In fact, only a century ago, nearly half of today’s independent nations were European colonies.

Imperialism, of course, had severe drawbacks.  For the colonized, these drawbacks included genocide, enslavement, exploitation, and the looting of resources.  But the colonizers, too, despite the vast riches acquired by a small minority among them, suffered losses.  They perished in imperialist wars, died of starvation and diseases, and became infected by arrogance, brutality and racism.  Above all, imperialism denied people in the colonies the right to self-government and, therefore, the right to determine the future of their own nations.

But World War II destabilized the imperialist system and, also, discredited it.  As a result, a vast wave of decolonization occurred in the aftermath of the war, especially in the 1950s and 1960s.  Although there are still holdouts from the worldwide anti-imperialist approach―Vladimir Putin, committed to annexing Ukraine, Benjamin Netanyahu, battling to prevent Palestinian statehood, and Donald Trump, constantly demanding new territory―for the most part national independence has become the acceptable norm.

The problem, however, is that although national independence is preferable to imperialist domination, it does not get us very far toward solving some of the world’s most pressing problems.

Perhaps the most serious of the problems facing us today is war, with wars currently raging throughout large portions of the world.  Global military spending continues to soar (reaching $2.9 trillion in 2025), with enormous increases already slated for the future.  The result is―and seems likely to continue to be―an enormous loss of lives and economic resources.

Nuclear weapons, of course, threaten to turn war into a catastrophe almost beyond human comprehension, annihilating virtually all life on earth.  And yet, in a sharp break with the nuclear arms control and disarmament measures of past decades, the nuclear powers have recently abandoned their commitment to reducing and, ultimately, abolishing the nuclear menace.  Having increased their nuclear spending by 19 percent in 2025, they are currently developing a dazzling array of new nuclear weapons.

How are nations going to deal with the immense problem of war and modern weaponry without collective action?  Certainly, the solution to the problem does not lie in the hands of any one nation.

If human beings, as well as other species, are not exterminated in the near future by war, they are likely to face gradual extinction by environmental catastrophe.  Global warming, the loss of biodiversity, air pollution, deforestation, melting ice caps, sea level rise, soil degradation, overfishing, and a host of other ills are already here and leading to an increasingly unsustainable, unlivable future.  Meanwhile, intense heat, raging wildfires, and massive floods are destroying agriculture and sending millions of desperate climate refugees fleeing from their homelands.

Effective protection of the world’s environment surpasses the ability of any one nation, however well-meaning.  Surely it is a global matter, requiring global cooperation.

Diseases, of course, also transcend national lines.  The COVID-19 pandemic, for example, caused between 15 million and 18 million deaths in nations around the world.  But, of course, in recent decades there have been other disease epidemics and pandemics that have shown no regard for national boundaries, including HIV/AIDS, malaria, influenza, hepatitis, SARS, swine flu, dengue fever, Western African Ebola, mpox, MERS, and cholera.

When it comes to diseases, there has been widespread recognition that a global approach is necessary.  As a result, 192 nations belong to the World Health Organization (WHO).  Three nations, however, stubbornly resist WHO membership.  The United States is one of them, thanks to the decision of U.S. President Trump to withdraw from it.

Numerous other challenges―including widespread poverty, the irresponsible behavior of multinational corporations, mass migration, resource scarcity, and the risks of advanced technologies like artificial intelligence―also suggest the need for global collaboration.

These kinds of global issues are frequently discussed at the United Nations, leading to statements made by the UN Secretary-General and other UN officials that appeal for remedial action.  But, unfortunately, some nations, and especially the great powers, which seem less committed to global betterment than to their own national agendas, have seen to it that the United Nations is denied the authority and the resources to adequately address these challenges.  Russia, for example, has repeatedly vetoed UN Security Council resolutions calling for an end to its continued military invasion, occupation, and annexation of Ukraine.  For its part, the United States has compiled a debt of nearly $4 billion to the cash-strapped United Nations by halting its payments for UN dues and UN peacekeeping operations.

The logical solution to the frustration of collective action is to strengthen the United Nations.  Several proposals have been advanced along these lines, including enhancing the power of the General Assembly and limiting the veto in the Security Council.  In addition, a campaign has recently been launched to reduce the obstacles to more effective UN action in global affairs by employing Article 109 of the UN Charter to hold a UN Charter review conference.  If this conference were held and the Charter revised, it could transform world organization into what the campaign calls “a stronger, fairer, and more inclusive international system.”

But the strengthening of the United Nations won’t occur automatically.  It will require worldwide public pressure, driven by citizens’ organizations committed to peace, environmental sustainability, public health, and other global imperatives.  Ultimately, it’s up to these organizations and to their allies among wise public officials to secure the next great shift in human consciousness and behavior―a shift from a parochial national independence to the interdependence of nations.

If war dead could speak

If war dead could speak

If those killed in war could speak, this is what I imagine they would say. They would claim that war is humanity’s biggest moral failure and that war is the real enemy. They might ask, “Are we savage animals or are we civilized human beings?” and “When will war be outlawed?” 

They might state, “We live in a world where the vilest of crimes―murder, torture, and rape―which are punished with severe consequences within most societies, are somehow accepted when committed as part of war.” They might think about how the organized murder of one group of humans by another group of humans, which is the definition of war, is encouraged by so many people. 

War has been an integral part of human history for some 11,000 years or so, depending on the definition of war. Iconic anthropologist Margaret Mead wrote an essay in 1940 that declared that, like so many other human practices, war is an invention—we are not doomed to wage war simply because of human nature. She proved her hypothesis simply by describing peoples that not only didn’t ever wage war, but often didn’t even have a concept of what war is.

In the nuclear age, it is the most imminent threat to our continued existence. As modern civilized people, most of us find war abhorrent, but few of us call for the abolition of war or understand why war still exists in the contemporary world.

War exists for many reasons:

  • One is because human society has been organized around the concept of the in-group and the out-group. The in-group could be a tribe, a city, a nation, a religion, a language group, or several associated nations. The out-group may be tolerated, but in many instances, it is considered the enemy. 
  • Sociologists point to relative deprivation, that is, when everyone is poor, that isn’t a conflict, but if we see one group living quite well while we are not, that can lead to conflict and has led ultimately to casus belli, a reason to wage war.

The question of our time is: can we create a new story in which humanity as a whole is the in-group? Can we civilize a lawless world by creating a basic system of rules, a system of enforceable global law?  

Having an understanding of what behavior is acceptable is the prerequisite to creating law. Law is the basis of civilization and allows for the nonviolent resolution of disputes. We currently live in a state of relative anarchy between nations, in which military power, rather than law, makes the rules. The greatest challenge of our time is bringing the rule of law to the global level, thereby replacing war with courts and parliaments. We have peace and order within most countries because of the enforceable rule of law, but between nations, international law is unenforceable, thus ineffective. 

The United Nations has succeeded in bringing almost all countries of the world together for dialogue and has laid the foundation for international law through many multilateral treaties. But the United Nations has fallen short because it lacks the enforcement mechanism that true law requires. The law is what protects individual citizens from criminal abuse. We are relatively safe in society because crimes are prosecuted and have consequences.  But, at the international level, laws between nations lack an enforcement mechanism. The United Nations is based on treaty law, a voluntary system of agreements between nations. Thus, it lacks an enforcement mechanism that true law provides. 

A new, more powerful, and democratic United Nations is needed to create peace among the world’s countries. 

Fortunately, transforming the United Nations along these lines is possible. Article 109 of the UN Charter provides a mechanism for initiating a UN Charter Review Conference. Such a conference would open the way to engaging the world’s countries in creating a rules-based system of international law that is enforceable rather than voluntary. In this new, more civilized world, based on law and rules rather than on military power, nations would no longer have the need or ability to engage in war.

Under Article 109 of the UN Charter, convening a global Charter review conference requires approval from three-fourths of the members of the General Assembly and nine members of the Security Council. The final approval of the conference results rests with the five permanent members of the Security Council―the United States, China, Russia, France, and Britain―each of which has veto power. If successful, the conference could transform the United Nations into a more effective international institution―one capable of enforcing laws among nations.

Admittedly, the ability of any of the five permanent members of the Security Council (the P5) to veto UN Charter revisions poses a potential obstacle to UN reform. Even so, implementing the UN Charter revision process will take considerable time, during which the most likely nay-sayers among the P5 governments may change, perhaps for the better. Moreover, a P5 recalcitrant might hesitate to exercise a veto at a momentous conference with overwhelming support for change. It is also possible that, when faced with one or two holdouts, the delegates to a UN Charter revision conference would surge beyond their original mandate and create a new, more effective system of global governance. 

To begin gathering public and diplomatic support for holding an appropriate Charter review conference, proponents of UN reform turned in September 2025 to launching the Article 109 Coalition during the annual UN General Assembly High-Level Week. Since then, the campaign has been picking up steam, with civil society groups like Citizens for Global Solutions working to mobilize U.S. support.

In their campaign, they can point to important evidence that strengthened governance reduces the likelihood of war. 

The countries of the European Union, for example, have achieved peace after thousands of years of warfare, including two world wars, by trading a small portion of their sovereignty for security. They now resolve disputes in the European Union’s parliament and courts. Similarly, countries around the world could achieve peace by establishing a global system of courts and parliaments through a transformation of the United Nations.

Just as slavery was abolished in the nineteenth century and is now illegal in all countries, war too can be abolished by law. Indeed, with the strengthening and enforcement of international law, war could become an obsolete relic of a barbaric past.