Is there a connection between mental illness and nuclear weapons?
The behavior of Donald Trump―whose mental stability has long been questioned by psychologists and other mental health professionals―has called attention to this issue. In March and early April of this year, he threatened to launch massive military strikes against Iranian energy and nuclear infrastructure, proclaiming on April 5: “There will be nothing like it!!! Open the Fuckin’ Strait, you crazy bastards, or you’ll be living in Hell – JUST WATCH!” On April 7, he warned: “A whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again. I don’t want that to happen, but it probably will.” Addressing the UN General Assembly on September 22, Trump threatened to “annihilate” Iran, saying that he could “drive them into hell with no chance of survival and no hope of future . . . generations.”
Assessing Trump’s UN diatribe, the Union of Concerned Scientists declared that it “constitutes an implied threat to use overwhelming nuclear force against Iran and the Iranian people”―a “nuclear genocide.”
Observers were aghast. U.S. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said Trump sounded like “a madman,” while Senator Bernie Sanders called Trump’s remarks “the ravings of a dangerous and mentally unstable person.” Referring to Trump’s rant on April 5, Senator Chris Murphy called it “absolute madness.” This May, 30 U.S. psychiatrists and other doctors specializing in mental health issued a statement declaring that Trump was mentally unfit to serve and warning that his ability to launch a nuclear weapons attack constituted a “danger” to the world. They noted, among other things, his “severely impaired judgment and impulse control,” “significant loss of self-control,” and “grandiose and delusional beliefs, including assertions of infallibility.”
Russia’s Vladimir Putin has also been diagnosed, repeatedly, as suffering from mental disorders. Certainly his behavior in connection with nuclear weapons has been remarkably menacing. According to a Voice of America report, Putin publicly issued 27 nuclear threats between February 2022 and December 2024. He talked of “preventive disarming nuclear strikes,” promised four times to nuke Germany if it delivered Leopard battle tanks to Ukraine, ordered Russian nuclear forces to simulate a nuclear attack on Ukraine, and announced that Russia’s strategic nuclear forces “are in a state of full combat readiness for a guaranteed use.” When, in a televised interview, the CEO of a state media giant asked Putin if Russia was ready for nuclear war, he responded blithely: “Weapons exist to be used.”
Nor are other leaders of nuclear-armed nations, such as North Korea’s Kim Jong Un, Israel’s Benjamin Netanyahu, and India’s Narendra Modi, paragons of mental health and military restraint.
Actually, the alarming connection between mental instability and nuclear weapons has long been evident. In March 1946, less than a year after the atomic bombings of Japan, an article appeared in The Saturday Review of Literature with the title: “Gentlemen: You are Mad!” The author, Lewis Mumford―a well-known American historian, sociologist, and philosopher of technology―explained: “The madmen are planning the end of the world. What they call continued progress in atomic warfare means universal extermination.”
In June 1957, when a group of prominent Americans met at New York City’s Overseas Press Club to consider what should be done about the issue of nuclear weapons testing, they adopted a similar stance. “The normal drive for survival has been put out of action by present propaganda,” remarked Erich Fromm, an eminent psychoanalyst. “We must . . . try to bring the voice of sanity to the people.” Establishing a new organization, they called it the National Committee for a Sane Nuclear Policy. SANE, as the new group was usually dubbed, began with the goal of halting nuclear testing but soon broadened that to securing nuclear disarmament.
As nuclear disarmament organizations emerged around the world in the late 1950s and early 1960s, they frequently depicted nuclear war as madness. SANE named its newsletter Sane World, while Britain’s Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and the Canadian Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament both called their newsletters Sanity.
Even government officials agreed on occasion that nuclear war was insane. In November 1957, as Nikita Khrushchev recalled, China’s Mao Zedong gave a speech that lauded nuclear war at a meeting of Communist party leaders from around the world. “We may lose more than three hundred million people,” Mao reportedly said. But “so what. War is war.” Finding Mao’s remarks “deeply disturbing,” Khrushchev came away convinced that his ally was a lunatic and eventually cut off Soviet assistance to China’s nuclear weapons program.
U.S. President John F. Kennedy also took up the nuclear insanity theme. Speaking before the UN General Assembly in September 1961, he warned that “every man, woman and child lives under a nuclear sword of Damocles, hanging by the slenderest of threads, capable of being cut at any moment by accident or miscalculation or by madness.” Two years later, in a major address on nuclear weapons and war, he cautioned that nuclear war could be launched “by a madman.”
Although, in the following decades, a combination of popular pressure and government response managed to curb the nuclear arms race and avert a nuclear catastrophe, the world seems once again in the grip of government officials all too eager to prepare for and launch a nuclear war.
This enormous nuclear danger magnifies the importance of the first review conference for the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, scheduled to occur at the United Nations from November 30 to December 4. Although signed by a majority of the world’s nations, this landmark treaty has been rejected thus far by the nuclear powers. But if they signed and implemented the treaty, it would effectively ban nuclear weapons and their immense danger to human survival.
Will humanity seize the opportunity offered by the treaty? Or are we all too mad to comprehend the fact that, as long as nuclear weapons exist, we live on the brink of nuclear annihilation?
Lawrence S. Wittner (https://www.lawrenceswittner.com/) is Professor of History Emeritus at SUNY/Albany, the author of Confronting the Bomb (Stanford University Press), and a Board member of the CGS Education Fund.
The United Nations, the first institution in history to represent the world community, is one of humanity’s great achievements.
But the structure of the United Nations, created in 1945, has often left it weak and ineffectual. The present confederal UN system includes 193 independent national governments and is based on the principle of national sovereignty. Have we really found the best way for these independent nations to decide upon policies for the world―policies that, hopefully, would foster peace, justice, and environmental sustainability?
A particularly promising way to facilitate UN collective decision-making and action would be to adopt a democratic system of weighted voting, a system suggested by the late Professor Joseph Schwartzberg in his path-breaking book, Transforming the United Nations: Designs for a Workable World (note: his method of reform was endorsed by some UN officials and other experts).
One of the biggest problems with the current structure of the United Nations is the “one-nation-one-vote” principle that is followed in the UN General Assembly and most other UN agencies. India with a population of 1.476 billion people, Tuvalu with a population of 9,000 people, and all of the 191 nations in between each have the same voting power in the General Assembly. Some nations pay a large percentage of the regular UN budget while most pay very little. It is therefore possible for 129 nations that together have only 8 percent of the world’s population and who pay only 1.271 percent of the UN budget to vote as a two-thirds majority on a substantive issue in the General Assembly. Sixty-five nations with a combined population below one percent of the world total can block passage of a substantive resolution.
In order to change General Assembly resolutions from being merely non-binding recommendations to legally binding obligations, Schwartzberg’s proposal involves calculating a weighted vote (WV) for each Member of the General Assembly by averaging three percentages: (1) its percentage of the total population of all UN members; (2) its financial contribution as a percentage of the UN budget; and (3) the percentage of the total number of members in the UN, which would be the same for every Member, now 1 out of 193 or 0.521 percent. The initial formula is therefore WV (Weighted Vote) = P (percent of population of UN) + C (financial contribution) + M (Members) / 3.
The United States has 4.558 percent of the world’s population, is assessed 22 percent of the UN budget, and is 0.521 percent of the Members of the United Nations. Averaging these three numbers would give the United States a weighted vote of 9.026. The weighted vote for China would be 9.640, for India 6.700, for Japan 3.543, for Germany 2.554, for France 2.047, and for Brazil 2.006. Ten countries would have a weighted vote between 1 and 2. For all other 176 Members, their weighted vote would each be less than 1.00. All of these percentages would need to be revised periodically because of changes in a nation’s population, its contribution to the UN budget, or the number of nations in the UN. Also, according to Schwartzberg, after years of increased democratization, the formula could be modified to 3P + 2C + M / 6.
Decisions of the General Assembly on global and general questions would be binding if made by a two-thirds majority of the weighted votes, provided that the total population of the concurring members represents a majority. On issues such as proposals for Charter revision and recommendations to the Security Council to impose sanctions on nations in serious violation of international law, Schwartzberg suggested that such proposals require as much as 75 percent of all weighted votes as well as approval by nations with at least two-thirds of the total population of all UN members.
Schwartzberg’s proposal for weighted voting could also apply to the composition of the UN Security Council. Under the present UN Charter, a resolution is passed with a three-fifths vote or 9 out of 15 countries that make up the Security Council at any one time without a veto by any one of the five permanent members (United States, Russia, China, United Kingdom, and France).
Schwartzberg recommended that a restructured Security Council be composed of 12 seats, each representing a major region of the world. He proposed that any single UN member for which the sum of its percentages of the world’s population and of contributions to the UN budget exceeds a threshold of 12 percent (currently, United States, China, and India) would be allowed to form its own region. The formula for any region would be the average of, (1) the combined population as a percentage of the total for all UN members, (2) the combined contribution to the UN as a percentage of the total for all UN members, and (3) 8.333, one-twelfth of 100 percent.
The twelve regions and their weighted vote would be: Europe (15.86); United States (12.53); China (12.24); India (9.30); Latin America (7.90); East Asia (7.24); sub-Saharan Africa (7.16); Southeast Asia (6.61); West Asia (6.49); Arab League (5.45); Russia and some neighboring countries (4.67); and the Westminster League, including Canada and Australia (4.54).
No country would have a veto.
Resolutions in the Security Council on procedural matters would require a simple majority vote while decisions on substantive matters would require a two-thirds majority and the concurrent approval by regions whose combined populations exceed 50 percent of the world’s total.
Schwartzberg argued that this system of weighted voting could be accomplished by simply amending a few sentences in Article 18 of the UN Charter.
Given the massive problems humanity currently faces from war, climate change, poverty, and disease, surely it’s time to find ways like weighted voting to enable international institutions to adequately address them.
David Oughton, who holds an interdisciplinary doctorate in Philosophies and Theologies of Peace and Justice, has taught courses about the world’s religions at Saint Louis University and is a Board member of the Citizens for Global Solutions Education Fund.
Lucy Law Webster spent almost eight decades working to end war through law. She died peacefully on Tuesday, November 3, 2026, at the age of 95. She was one of the longest serving members of the movement Citizens for Global Solutions grew from, and a friend and mentor to many of us.
Lucy wrote her first anti-war poem at nine, in response to the Second World War. It was published in Parents Magazine and imagined a day “when all the world’s laws obey.” At sixteen she started a world federalist chapter at Miss Fine’s School in Princeton, New Jersey. The town chapter met in Albert Einstein’s house on Mercer Street, and her student group was invited in. “He was charismatic with his white wild hair and inspired us all in our push for peace and world government,” she later wrote.
At Wellesley College she was elected national student chairman of the United World Federalists in 1952. She linked student groups at Harvard, MIT, Smith, Mount Holyoke and Wellesley into a New England council. In 1954 she represented the World Student Federalists at the World Assembly of Youth in Singapore. Some fifty chapters across the United States each sent $35 to “send Lucy Law around the world.” She repaid them with a year of talks in their towns, from Seattle to Florida.
Lucy married David Webster in 1955 and settled in London, where she built a career in marketing research and raised two sons. She chaired the Executive Committee of the international World Federalist Movement for a number of years, including at its 1980 congress in Tokyo.
In the early 1980s she moved to New York to work for UNICEF and then the United Nations Secretariat. She served as special assistant to the Secretary General of the Second World Conference to Combat Racism. Most of her UN career was spent as a Political Affairs Officer in the Department for Disarmament Affairs. She edited two UN disarmament publications and was liaison to the press and civil society at the 1990 and 1995 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty review conferences.
Retirement did not slow her down. She led Economists for Peace and Security as Executive Director and later served as its board secretary. She was Executive Director of the Center for War/Peace Studies, Vice Chair of the Council of the World Federalist Movement, and President of the New York chapter of Citizens for Global Solutions. From 2011 to 2020 she served on the board of the Citizens for Global Solutions Education Fund. As chair of the World Federalist Institute, she helped keep the organization’s founding ideas alive inside CGS. In 2019 she received the CGS Lifetime Achievement Award at our meeting in Los Angeles.
“When I first learned of the idea of a democratic world federation and wanted to get involved in the movement, she welcomed and encouraged me,” said Donna Park, former chair of the CGS Education Fund board. “I will always remember her fondly and with deep appreciation.”
“I was honored to work side by side with her for four decades,” said Larry David, chair of the CGS Education Fund board. “She was always there, always committed to the big outrageous goals of the world federalists, always smiling, always welcoming and always getting it done on our projects. Lucy was one of a kind that they don’t make any more.”
Lucy Law Webster. Photo courtesy of Larry David.
Lucy told her own story in a short memoir, My Life as a World Federalist. She ended it this way:
I’ve often viewed this struggle for a world government like walking up a down escalator. It’s not the easiest thing to do, but it’s better to walk up than just stand there!
My life as a world federalist has been exciting and rewarding even though we haven’t reached the summit. I sincerely hope that a new generation will get there and we will have lasting world peace.
Citizens for Global Solutions sends its deepest sympathy to Lucy’s family and to everyone she brought into this work. The best way to honor her is the one she asked for: a new generation taking the next step up.
Photos courtesy of the Webster family and Larry David.
For millennia, the world’s people have been kidding themselves about national security.
Worried about the survival of their nation in a world of self-interested, sometimes aggressive nations, people have armed and prepared themselves for war. Only military strength, they have assumed, would fend off or defeat a military attack on their nation.
And a case can be made for this assumption, for not all nations―and not all people―are willing to deal peacefully or justly with their neighbors.
Even so, over the course of human history, this reliance upon national military might to defend national security has produced disaster after disaster. Although almost every country has armed itself for national defense, even those with immense military might have ended up fighting recurring wars to defend what they regard as their national security. Just look at the history of the “great powers” of recent centuries―the United States, Russia, China, Britain, France, Germany, and Japan―and consider how frequently they have waged war, sometimes emerging as the victors and other times as the vanquished.
Furthermore, preparing for and fighting wars, even victorious wars, have come at an immense human cost. Estimates for the death toll in the almost constant flow of wars over the span of human history range as high as 1 billion people. And to this we should add the vast numbers of people crippled, blinded, traumatized, and left homeless. Russia’s current military invasion of Ukraine, aside from slaughtering large numbers of Ukrainians, has already led to the deaths or injuries of 1,581,840 Russian soldiers. During World War II, Soviet military and civilian deaths reached 24,000,000.
Nuclear war, of course, promises to increase war’s human toll very substantially, with the living, as is sometimes said, envying the dead.
Nevertheless, the nations of the world continue, relentlessly, to arm and prepare themselves for war. Global military expenditures rose by nearly 3 percent in 2025, the eleventh consecutive year of growth, reaching $2.9 trillion. America’s Donald Trump, a fervent supporter of U.S. military power, has proposed a 42 percent increase in the forthcoming U.S. military budget to $1.5 trillion―about 63 percent of federal discretionary spending.
Of course, far-sighted individuals have criticized militarism and war, as well as suggested better ways for nations to relate to one another. Thanks particularly to the massive slaughter and destruction wrought by the two World Wars, they called for the development of international institutions that could safeguard national security through the development and enforcement of international law. This agitation led to the establishment of the League of Nations (and its legal arm, the Permanent Court of International Justice) and, near the end of World War II, to the establishment of the League’s successor, the United Nations (and its legal arm, the International Court of Justice).
These new institutions were met with considerable enthusiasm by a war-weary public, and even by many national officials, who recognized that, if every country continued blindly pursuing what it viewed as its own interests, global conflict and war were inevitable.
But this potential turning point in human history was bedeviled by two major problems. For thousands of years, nations had defended their “interests” (and especially their national security) through military might. Consequently, many government officials and even many members of the public were not accustomed to thinking and behaving according to what best served the common good. Furthermore, the great powers were particularly reluctant to surrender the advantages, including empire, that military might traditionally afforded them in world affairs.
As a result, the leaders of the major powers, despite their rhetoric about the equality of nations and collective action to cope with international issues, remained committed to ensuring a privileged status for their own countries.
In the case of the League of Nations, this reluctance to accept limits meant that the great power victors in World War I came away from the peace settlement with new territory, including the spoils of empire (disguised as “mandates”), taken from the war’s great power losers. Moreover, in subsequent years, the Axis nations plunged into war to restore their empires or enhance them, while they and other major powers withdrew from the League when it condemned their belligerent behavior. The U.S. government never even joined the League.
When it came to the United Nations, the great power victors in World War II established a UN Security Council that provided each of them with a veto over collective action for international security. Thus, they could (and did) veto such action when they felt it adversely affected them or their friends. They also pursued what they regarded as their national security by subverting, invading, and even occupying other nations, while occasionally withholding their dues payments to the world organization.
Against this backdrop, it’s easy to conclude that international security has failed the test.
But, given the existence of key international institutions for only a tiny portion of human history, isn’t it premature to abandon efforts to create an effective international security system? After all, the United Nations is only 81 years old. By contrast, modern human beings have been around for about 300,000 years.
Also, what is the alternative? Surely it is endless war, capped off by the use of nuclear weapons to annihilate the human race.
So, in our current predicament, let’s give some thought to strengthening the world’s international institutions.
Numerous nations have called for reforming the United Nations. Modest measures, such as providing it with adequate funding and enhancing the role of the General Assembly, can be fairly easily implemented. More significant changes―for example, abolishing the Security Council veto―will take a more substantial effort, including the holding of a UN Charter review conference. Article 109 of the UN Charter provides the framework for such a conference, and an Article 109 Coalition has recently launched a campaign to prepare for it.
Over thousands of years, war and militarism have failed to safeguard national security. But international security might finally succeed at the task.
Lawrence S. Wittner (https://www.lawrenceswittner.com/) is Professor of History Emeritus at SUNY/Albany, the author of Confronting the Bomb (Stanford University Press), and a Board member of the CGS Education Fund.
On October 9, 2026, the United States imposed sanctions on the International Criminal Court as an institution. The Court is the only permanent tribunal where victims of genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity can seek justice when national courts cannot or will not act.
Citizens for Global Solutions has joined the Coalition for the International Criminal Court and more than 180 organizations from over 60 countries in calling on the 125 States Parties to the Rome Statute to protect the Court they created. The full joint statement follows.
Urgent Call for Action: States Must Act Now to Protect the International Criminal Court from Unlawful US Attacks
The Coalition for the International Criminal Court (CICC), the more than 180 undersigned organisations from over 60 countries representing all regions, and dozens of legal experts, human rights defenders and members of the European Parliament, condemn unequivocally and in the strongest terms the decision by the United States (US) to impose unlawful sanctions on the International Criminal Court (ICC). This unprecedented measure represents a direct attack against the rule of law, the independence of the Court and international justice, ultimately undermining the rights of millions of victims and survivors of mass atrocities worldwide.
The ICC has shown remarkable resilience in steadfastly discharging its mandate in the face of escalating attacks. Now, States Parties must match this commitment by defending the Court they themselves established and protecting those who cooperate with it. Condemnations alone are not enough; coordinated action is urgently needed to protect the Court’s ability to function.
On 9 October 2026, the US announced the imposition of sanctions against the ICC as an institution under Executive Order 14203. These sanctions mark the gravest escalation in the sustained campaign carried out by the US with the declared aim of dismantling the ICC “brick by brick” for having investigated crimes allegedly committed on the territory of a State Party by US nationals or their allies, in particular Israeli nationals. Under the Rome Statute, the Court may exercise jurisdiction over crimes committed on the territory of a State Party, irrespective of the nationality of the alleged perpetrator.
Since February 2025, the Trump administration has imposed sanctions on the former ICC Prosecutor, Karim Khan; both Deputy Prosecutors; the ICC President and eight other judges; a staff member and judicial candidate; a UN Special Rapporteur; and three Palestinian human rights organisations.
These measures aim to undermine the Rome Statute system as a whole and to prevent the investigation and prosecution of international crimes.
Executive Order 14203 prohibits US persons from providing material support or services to designated persons and entities, including financial services, and exposes non-US persons to the risk of secondary sanctions for engaging in conduct prohibited under the Executive Order. US persons who violate it may face criminal penalties of up to 20 years’ imprisonment and fines of up to 1 million USD, as well as civil penalties.
Although the Executive Order contains a six month wind-down period and exemptions for certain services, significant risks remain. Given the global reliance on the US financial and IT systems, even non-US service providers, including banks, may stop rendering their services to the ICC out of fear of penalties or reprisals from the US Treasury. This could impact the Court’s ability to maintain a bank account, receive financial contributions from States Parties, make payments, pay staff and maintain essential operations.
The Netherlands, as the host country, and all States Parties are responsible for ensuring the ICC can maintain access to services critical to its operations. The Court must be able to continue to carry out its core functions, including investigating alleged crimes; holding hearings; protecting victims and witnesses; and providing legal aid services.
For victims, survivors and witnesses in more than a dozen situation countries under investigation by the Court across the globe, the consequences could be profound. Many have waited years for justice, recounted traumatic experiences and placed their trust in the ICC as a last resort for justice. Any disruption to the ICC’s mandate and operations risks impeding their right to justice. It threatens decades of advances in accountability and justice efforts, leaving victims of war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide without a meaningful prospect for accountability, truth and reparations.
The sanctions are already undermining justice efforts. The three Palestinian NGOs designated for cooperating with the Court immediately lost access to their bank accounts, funds, IT services and partners, impeding their work. The damage does not end with those targeted; the sanctions have created a chilling effect and impacted freedom of expression and association worldwide. Sanctions on the Court as an institution risk deepening that effect. Ultimately, victims, families of victims and survivors will pay the biggest price.
The US, which is not a State Party, is blatantly attacking the world’s only permanent international criminal court through measures that leverage its position within the global financial system. If the 125 States Parties to the Rome Statute allow these attacks to undermine the Court’s ability to function, the consequences would extend far beyond the ICC, threatening the broader rule of law, states’ sovereignty and systems of justice at the national, regional and international levels.
Statements of concern and condemnations are no longer a sufficient response to this attack. A coordinated response can no longer be delayed. Three decades ago, States made a promise that no one, no matter how powerful, will be shielded from accountability for international crimes. Victims and survivors have waited decades for a Court capable of delivering justice regardless of power or nationality, and today, the ICC is facing unprecedented pressure precisely because it seeks to apply the law equally. States Parties established the Court and are uniquely placed to safeguard its independence and effectiveness. Failure to respond decisively risks weakening the international justice system they pledged to uphold.
The CICC calls on all States Parties, individually and collectively, to:
Denounce publicly, unequivocally, in the strongest terms possible and at the highest political level the institutional sanctions against the ICC and those cooperating with it as an unlawful attack on judicial independence, the rule of law and victims.
Immediately adopt or activate blocking measures at the national and regional level – including the immediate adoption of the EU Blocking Statute (Council Regulation (EC) No 2271/96) and equivalent domestic legislation elsewhere – to shield those designated, including the Court and its officials, the UN Special Rapporteur and civil society organisations, from the extraterritorial reach of these sanctions.
Guarantee that the Court and those cooperating with it can have access to banking and other essential services, including by:
Providing legal certainty to service providers by taking a clear legal position on the non-extraterritorial application of sanctions and making this legal position publicly available through letters or written statements.
Engaging proactively and regularly with banks, financial institutions, IT companies and others to reaffirm the unlawfulness of the sanctions, clarify that they should not be enforced extra-territorially, reject over-compliance or de-risking strategies and stop automatic or externalised compliance.
Ensure that all relevant ministries, including foreign affairs, justice, finance, treasury and digital affairs, coordinate, including at the regional level, to develop whole-of-government solutions.
Apply protection and solutions equally to civil society, human rights defenders and survivors targeted with sanctions or at risk due to their cooperation with the Court, extending every statement, solution, démarche and funding measure to include civil society organisations designated and those at risk, without distinction.
Find concrete measures to mitigate the impact of sanctions on civic space, freedom of speech and freedom of association.
Build and invest in economic, financial and tech sovereignty and resilience to reduce structural dependency on US service providers.
Explore all possible diplomatic and legal avenues to challenge the sanctions and their legality under international law, including by supporting any legal challenge raised by designated persons in the US and through a referral to the International Court of Justice.
Publicly and strongly reaffirm their commitment to the Rome Statute and continue to comply fully with their obligations under the Rome Statute, including funding, cooperation and the arrest and surrender of all persons subject to ICC warrants, without exception, delay, or selectivity.
Publicly and clearly oppose any initiatives aimed at weakening the Court, including attempts to amend the Rome Statute to limit its jurisdiction or independence and attempts to influence prosecutorial priorities, including efforts to sideline specific situations, such as Afghanistan or Palestine.
Refuse, without exception, coercion by a non-State Party to influence votes, positions, or conduct within the ASP or any other body of the Rome Statute system.
Ensure any ICC-related meeting is held in a country that ICC officials and staff and civil society organisations, including those designated, can access safely and without threats.
On October 9, only hours after the announcement of the award of the Nobel Peace Prize to Navi Pillay, a former judge on the International Criminal Court (ICC), the Trump administration imposed its latest sanctions on the global judicial body. According to Secretary of State Marco Rubio, “we will ban transactions with this rogue court, cutting off their resources and crippling its ability to operate.”
When the ICC became operational in 2002, it represented a major breakthrough for the human rights groups that had campaigned for it. The new organization had the mandate to prosecute individuals for genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity and, after 2018, the crime of aggression. Once nations ratified the ICC’s authorizing document, the Rome Statute, they took responsibility for arresting these individuals and submitting them to the Court for trial. Designed to complement, rather than to replace, national criminal justice systems, the ICC could prosecute cases only when countries were unwilling or unable to do so. A total of 125 countries―nearly two-thirds of the world’s nations―have ratified the Rome Statute.
Although U.S. officials played a role in crafting the Rome Statute, they were far from enthusiastic about the statute and the ICC. President Bill Clinton did sign the statute. Even so, he refused to present it to the U.S. Senate for ratification, warning that it had “significant flaws,” including the inability to “protect U.S. officials.” Clinton’s successor, George W. Bush, took a harder line. After “unsigning” the statute in 2002, he signed U.S. legislation, the American Servicemembers’ Protection Act, authorizing military force to liberate any American or allied nationals the ICC held for crimes. Nevertheless, amid the “War on Terror,” the Bush administration and, later, the Obama administration, cooperated on occasion with the Court, declining to use the UN Security Council veto to block an ICC investigation and voting for Security Council referral of the situation in Libya to the Court.
During Trump’s first term as President, however, U.S. policy toward the ICC turned sharply hostile. Denouncing the ICC before the UN General Assembly, he declared that the U.S. government would “provide no support or recognition” to it. As far as the United States was concerned, he said, “the ICC has no jurisdiction, no legitimacy, and no authority.” Trump also imposed economic sanctions and visa restrictions on top ICC officials for any effort to investigate the behavior of U.S. personnel in Afghanistan.
Russian officials, too, eventually realized that enforcement of international law threatened them. Although, initially, the Russian government signed the Rome Statute and participated constructively in the ICC, it withdrew its signature after Ukraine appealed to the ICC in 2014 and 2015 to investigate Russian war crimes in Ukraine. The ICC did initiate a preliminary inquiry that, after the full-scale Russian invasion of 2022 and Russia’s murder of Ukrainian civilians and prisoners of war in Bucha, expanded into a formal investigation. In 2023, the ICC issued arrest warrants for Russian President Vladimir Putin and Commissioner for Children’s Rights Maria Lvova-Belova for the kidnapping of thousands of Ukrainian children.
With Trump’s re-election, the campaign to destroy the ICC went into high gear. In February 2025, he imposed sanctions on the ICC prosecutor. That August, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, labeling the Court “a national security threat,” added ICC judges to the sanctions list. In late 2025, a top Trump administration official told Reuters that there was “growing concern” that “the ICC will turn its attention to the president, to the vice president, to the secretary of war and others, and pursue prosecutions against them.” That was “unacceptable, and we will not allow it to happen.” The ICC, he said, had been informed that, unless it amended its founding document to ensure that it would not investigate the Republican president and his top officials, new, very punishing U.S. sanctions would be imposed on the Court.
The Russian government also ramped up its attack. In December 2025, a Russian court, retaliating for the ICC’s arrest warrants for Putin and Lvova-Belova, convicted the ICC prosecutor and eight ICC judges, in absentia, of “unlawful prosecution,” sentencing them to terms of imprisonment ranging from 3-1/2 to 15 years.
In July 2026, Rubio announced what the U.S. State Department called “a sweeping campaign to dismantle the threat posed by the International Criminal Court to U.S. sovereignty.” It would “feature a whole-of-government response to systematically disable the ICC’s ability to operate” and destroy the Court “brick by brick.” That August, imposing additional sanctions on Court officials, Rubio proclaimed “our unwavering mission to protect Americans from this sham of a court.” Meanwhile, U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth called on Latin American and Caribbean governments to sever their ties with the ICC.
Many observers, of course, were appalled by the Trump administration’s behavior. The European Union immediately expressed its backing for the ICC, while Germany’s Foreign Minister declared that the Court made the world “safer and more just.” In a biting article, Kenneth Roth, a former executive director of Human Rights Watch, argued that “the administration’s real goal is to secure impunity for war crimes.”
Nevertheless, the campaign against the ICC is having a serious impact. In late July, thanks to U.S. government pressure, Venezuela and Chad announced their withdrawal from the Court’s Rome Statute. The number of withdrawals now stands at five, including Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger. The latter three are ruled by military juntas allied with Russia.
As the Nobel committee warned when announcing the Peace Prize, the “judges and institutions of international law are under political attack.”
If the attack succeeds, it will produce a disaster not only for the rule of law, but for the cause of human rights.
Although the speeches of Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu dominated mass media coverage of the 81st session of the UN General Assembly, which opened in September 2026, the event also included the announcement of a far more significant matter: a campaign to address the problem of worldwide economic inequality.
On September 24, standing in for South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, Ronald Lamola, South Africa’s Minister of International Relations and Cooperation, told General Assembly delegates that “the promise of democracy and international cooperation wanes when we cannot demonstrate that they can address inequality and insecurity.” Thus, “together with Brazil, Norway, and Spain, South Africa calls on this Assembly to throw its weight behind the establishment” of an International Panel on Inequality (IPI). Based on the model of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the IPI would research inequality within and between countries and develop policies to close the widening gap between the rich and the poor.
That gap is enormous. As Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz and other specialists have recently reported, “the richest 10 percent of adults globally receives more than half (53 percent) of the world’s income, whereas the poorest half receives 8 percent.” When it comes to wealth, that “is even more concentrated, with the richest 10 percent owning around three-quarters of global wealth while the poorest half owns just 2 percent.” And “almost two-thirds of people live in countries where inequality is rising.” In turn, this economic inequality leads to “unequal access to education, health care, housing and finance,” factors shaping “the opportunities that direct people’s lives.”
The speech at the General Assembly, as well as the specialists’ report, originated with developments within the G20, an international forum of nations with advanced and emerging economies seeking to coordinate global economic policy. In 2025, when the South African government held the presidency of the G20, it commissioned a study of global inequality by independent experts and chaired by Stiglitz. Appearing last November, the study maintained that “inequality is one of the most urgent concerns in the world today,” and that “combating it is necessary and possible.” Indeed, according to the study, the inequality emergency was on a par with the climate emergency, and an IPI, once established, would gather information on the problem and propose solutions to it.
Recently, the campaign for a global response to global economic inequality has picked up momentum. By mid-September 2026, when the UN General Assembly session was underway, more than 1,500 economists and academics from more than 100 countries had signed an open letter backing the creation of an International Panel on Inequality. Among the high-profile signatories were former U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, Nobel Prize-winning economist Daron Acemoglu, and numerous other prominent economists, including Thomas Piketty, Mariana Mazzucato, and Jayati Ghosh. In the letter, they maintained that “extreme concentrations of income and wealth translate into undemocratic concentrations of power, unravelling trust in our societies and polarizing our politics.”
Ghosh remarked: “India’s experience tells us everything we need to know about why an International Panel on Inequality is needed. One of the world’s fast-growing economies is also one of its most unequal and its extraordinary wealth sits alongside profound deprivation.”
Meanwhile, the IPI proposal drew important support from other quarters. At a BRICS summit during the second week in September, Brazil and South Africa put the issue on the meeting’s agenda, resulting in a final communique that called for “concrete steps” to “establish an international panel on inequality.” Later in the month, 38 former heads of state and government from the Club of Rome published an open letter urging world leaders to establish the IPI. They included Germany’s Olaf Scholz, Ireland’s Leo Varadkar, Nigeria’s Olusegun Obasanjo, Malawi’s Joyce Banda, and New Zealand’s Helen Clark.
This buildup culminated not only in the South African address to the General Assembly, but in a side event this September at the United Nations, to which all UN member states were invited by the governments of Brazil, Norway, South Africa, and Spain to show their support for the creation of the IPI. At the gathering, the Prime Minister of Barbados, Mia Mottley, delivered a passionate speech, declaring: “Greed is man-made, and therefore . . . it can be unman-made.” She was joined that day by delegations from other nations that displayed their backing for the IPI venture, including Germany, Japan, Bangladesh, Uruguay, and Mexico.
The campaigners hope to generate enough international support to get the UN General Assembly, during this session, to pass a resolution formally establishing the new panel on international inequality.
This will not be an easy task. After all, many nations are headed by officials whose priority appears to be enriching their wealthiest individuals and their giant corporations. As Sarah Colenbrander, the director of the climate and sustainability program at the London-based ODI Global, has observed: “It is hard to imagine that billionaires―and the world leaders among them or in their pockets”―would support wealth redistribution. This year’s G20 meeting, scheduled for December, will not be presided over by South Africa’s Cyril Ramaphosa, but by America’s Donald Trump.
Even so, egalitarian forces―including social justice activists, labor unions, and progressive politicians―have excellent reasons to rally behind the establishment of a UN panel on international inequality, for it opens up the possibility of economic and social transformation on a global basis. Furthermore, as proponents of the panel realize, they possess substantial strength in the UN General Assembly, where impoverished nations are numerous and where, unlike in the UN Security Council, a majority vote cannot be vetoed by a wealthy and powerful nation.
Of course, there has been a persistent struggle between rich and poor within societies and nations over the course of human history. In this case, however, the class struggle has reached the global level, with the possibility of global action to address the scandal of vast economic inequality.
Canada and the United States have frequently maintained that they have a special relationship, characterized by the world’s longest undefended international border, peaceful interaction, common values, and a close defense partnership through NATO.
Nevertheless, the two nations are currently locked in an increasingly destructive battle.
Mark Carney, having replaced Trudeau as leader of the Liberal Party as nationwide parliamentary elections loomed, responded bluntly: “America is not Canada, and Canada never, ever will be part of America in any way, shape, or form.” Canadians seemed to agree, for, in response to Trump’s incendiary remarks, they gave the new Liberal leader and his party―initially trailing by huge margins in polls on the forthcoming elections―a stunning election victory.
Trump’s arrogant attitude toward Canada reflects not only his belief that the United States should dominate the Western Hemisphere, but his assumption that the U.S. government, with its vast economy, has the upper hand when it comes to its relationship with Canada. Because the United States purchases the bulk of Canadian exports while Canada purchases only a small fraction of America’s vast exports, “we don’t need Canada,” Trump explained, “they need us!”
In these circumstances, it’s hardly surprising that Trump, a keen admirer of the tariff, has weaponized it to bring Canada to heel. This August, dissatisfied with the Canadian response to his trade demands, he slapped a 50 percent tariff on Canadian imports into the United States. Canada “wants the benefits of being a State, without being one,” he complained.
Carney responded: “Last spring, I warned that America is trying to break us so that they can own us. And promised: ‘That will never, ever happen.’ We are keeping that promise.”
Canadians overwhelmingly approved of Carney’s stance. Polling conducted shortly after U.S.-Canadian talks collapsed indicated that three-quarters of Canadians agreed with Carney. Even Doug Ford, the conservative Premier of Ontario, said Carney had his “full support” and that Trump could “kiss my ass.”
Clearly, something has happened to the friendly relationship between the two nations.
Actually, it was not always so friendly. During the War of 1812 between Britain and the United States, U.S. military forces invaded Canada in the hope of seizing portions of it and annexing them to the United States. But they were soundly defeated by British troops, Canadian militia, and their Native American allies. American enthusiasm for annexing portions of Canada flared up again during the 1840s, when British and American joint control of the Oregon Territory was opposed by those who, rallying behind the slogan “Fifty-four Forty or Fight,” demanded it all. Ultimately, though, the territory was divided at the 49th parallel, with the northern half becoming British Columbia and the southern half forming the states of Oregon and Washington. Cross-border violence, though, did flare up from 1866 to 1871, when armed bands of Irish-Americans conducted Fenian raids on British army forts, customs posts, and other Canadian border targets in an unsuccessful attempt to trade Canada for Irish independence.
Beginning in the 1870s, however, Canadian-American relations improved considerably. Disputes over maritime rights and boundaries were settled amicably, while military alliances between the two governments during the two world wars and the Cold War helped foster good feelings between officials and the public of both nations. Friction did develop, at times, over trade policies, as well as over the Canadian government’s more peace-oriented foreign policy, which included closer cooperation with the League of Nations and the United Nations, plus stronger support for nuclear arms control and disarmament. Canadian public opinion was usually strongly pro-American―at least until the advent of Donald Trump, when such opinion dropped precipitously. Also, unlike Trump, 80 percent of Americans have a favorable view of Canada.
Sadly, then, the many years of increasingly friendly relations between Canada and the United States have been sabotaged by Trump’s reckless, domineering behavior.
Of course, the cordial relationship between the two North American nations could be restored by a variety of future developments, including a sharp repudiation of Trump in the November 2026 U.S. Congressional elections, his departure from public office, or merely his sudden obsession with another issue.
Even so, the ease with which the Canadian-American relationship has been damaged illustrates the fragility of international relations and, more specifically, the fact that centuries of growing cooperation among nations can be upended by the sudden tantrums or crackpot nostrums of individuals. Indeed, the current situation is all too reminiscent of how deranged and power-mad national rulers wrecked the international order in the past.
Remedying this deeper problem of international fragility calls for a shift toward a world order more strongly grounded in international law. Following this law, developed by the global community, would provide a considerably more rational and effective way to handle international disputes and foster international cooperation.
Thanks to centuries of effort, there are currently international institutions―for example, the United Nations, the International Court of Justice, and the International Criminal Court―that create this international law and interpret it.
Admittedly, these international institutions remain relatively weak, largely because the rulers of powerful nations prefer to bypass them so that they can keep the reins of power in their own hands. Nevertheless, with public effort, these institutions can be strengthened so that they can more effectively perform their vital role of safeguarding the human community.
The current crisis in U.S.-Canadian relations is the latest indication that it’s time to get on with that job.
Starvation is a particularly cruel and horrible way to die. Beginning with intense hunger and pain and followed by exhaustion and mental deterioration, starvation continues with the body gradually consuming its own tissues on a downward spiral toward death.
The major safeguard against mass starvation around the globe is the World Food Program (WFP), which received the Nobel Peace Prize in 2020 for its vital humanitarian work. With hundreds of millions of people in jeopardy thanks to poverty, famines, violent conflict, and extreme weather, this UN agency distributes massive quantities of food aid―last year alone, reaching more than 100 million people facing acute hunger―thereby saving millions of lives.
But with the advent of the second Trump administration in January 2025, the World Food Program, which in 2024 received nearly half of its funding from the U.S. government, entered a period of crisis that has only deepened in the months since then.
On his first day in office, President Donald Trump signed an executive order freezing all U.S. foreign assistance, declaring that the “foreign aid industry and bureaucracy are not aligned with American interests and in many cases [are] antithetical to American values.” Within short order, the DOGE operation of multibillionaire Elon Musk terminated the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), which provided the bulk of U.S. overseas humanitarian aid to impoverished nations. Calling USAID a “criminal organization,” Musk declared that it was “time for it to die.”
Emergency food assistance, a component of U.S. foreign aid, was a key administration target. In April 2025, the Trump administration ended funding to the WFP for food programs in 14 of the world’s most impoverished nations. Responding to the action, the WFP warned that “this could amount to a death sentence for millions of people facing extreme hunger and starvation.”
Thanks almost entirely to the shift in U.S. policy, the WFP experienced a 40 percent drop in funding during 2025.
The results of the financial cutbacks were horrific. In Kenya, where the Trump administration abruptly ended all U.S. funding for WFP operations, there resided about 720,000 refugees, among the most vulnerable people on earth. Although aid workers and local U.S. officials repeatedly appealed for a renewal of U.S. food assistance, none was forthcoming. As a result, a ProPublica study reported, the refugees “began to starve, and many―mostly children―died because their malnourished bodies couldn’t fight off infections.” In these circumstances, “mothers had to choose which of their kids to feed. Young men took to the streets in protests, some of which devolved into violent riots. Pregnant women with life-threatening anemia were so desperate for calories that they ate mud.”
Elsewhere, too, the situation grew increasingly desperate. In numerous impoverished nations where special packets of food paste had been distributed to 9.3 million children on the brink of starvation, the packets virtually disappeared. In one region of Nigeria alone, 150 clinics, operated by the WFP and providing nutrition treatment for 300,000 children below the age of two, shut down in July 2025.
Meanwhile, the Trump administration pressed for further cuts in overseas U.S. food aid. Trump’s FY 2026 budget proposal, advanced in May 2025, called for the elimination of two long-established U.S. ventures partially channeled through the WFP—the Food for Peace program and the McGovern-Dole child nutrition program. But, as things turned out, Republican legislators with agricultural constituencies blocked the move. Anxious to keep farmers happy by providing a market for their excess commodities distributed through the programs, they joined Democrats in re-enacting both of them, though with a 23 percent cut in funding.
The Trump administration, however, remains determined to destroy what’s left of the existing U.S. government overseas food assistance program. In April 2026, its FY 2027 budget proposal called for the total elimination of the Food for Peace and the McGovern-Dole programs. For the first time since the establishment of the World Food Program in 1961, no U.S. funding has been earmarked for that UN agency.
Admittedly, the dumping of surplus agricultural commodities from wealthy nations, especially when such commodity production is subsidized by their governments, can worsen food insecurity in impoverished nations by undermining their local agriculture. Although this situation could be remedied by subsidizing the food production of small farmers in impoverished lands, the Trump administration seems unlikely to do so.
Instead, this August, probably to deflect public criticism of the collapse of humanitarian assistance and to win favor with Trump’s religious base, the administration announced a new initiative for distribution of overseas humanitarian aid under the direction of Christian organizations. Compared to the U.S. government’s humanitarian aid of the past (e.g., $8 billion in 2024), the total funding was minuscule: $2 billion over five years. Moreover, although the new program would apparently provide some food assistance, it wouldn’t amount to much, as nearly three-quarters of the total funding was allocated for healthcare.
Naturally, thanks to the collapse of traditional U.S. food assistance policy, world hunger and starvation have soared. According to the WFP, “a staggering 266 million people are . . . facing crisis levels of hunger or worse” in 2026. Meanwhile, “severe funding shortfalls are forcing WFP to scale back assistance,” and “lost lives . . . will be the price to pay.”
Clearly, a new direction is needed to avert massive human suffering and death. In the immediate future, other wealthy nations could step up to fill the funding gap left by the Trump administration. Longer term, the United Nations and its agencies could be provided with an independent source of income, thereby ending their dependence on the whims of individual nations―especially those nations directed by people so fantastically wealthy that they lack any comprehension of hunger and its effects.
Until remedial action is taken, however, world hunger and starvation will continue as a disgrace to humanity.
Citizens for Global Solutions (CGS) is pleased to welcome Dr. Arthur Lyon Dahl as the newest member of our National Advisory Council (NAC). A leading voice on global environmental governance, United Nations reform, and sustainable development, Dr. Dahl brings decades of experience working at the intersection of environmental science, international institutions, and global cooperation.
Based in Geneva, Switzerland, Dr. Dahl is President of the International Environment Forum and a retired Deputy Assistant Executive Director of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). During his career with UNEP, he served as Deputy Director of Oceans and Coastal Areas in Nairobi and Coordinator of the UN System-wide Earthwatch in Geneva.
An environmental scientist specializing in coral reefs, Dr. Dahl spent 11 years in New Caledonia as Regional Ecological Adviser to the Pacific Islands and helped organize the Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP). He also served in the secretariat of the landmark 1992 Rio Earth Summit, where he contributed to drafting the Oceans chapter of Agenda 21.
His engagement with international environmental governance spans more than five decades. He participated in the 1972 UN Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm, the 2002 World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, Rio+20 in 2012, Stockholm+50 in 2022, and major UN Climate Change Conferences, including COP15 in Copenhagen and COP21 in Paris.
Dr. Dahl’s scholarship has increasingly focused on the institutional reforms necessary to respond to challenges that transcend national borders. He co-authored Global Governance and the Emergence of Global Institutions for the 21st Century and, with Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen, Towards a Global Environment Agency: Effective Governance for Shared Ecological Risks. His recent work focuses particularly on United Nations reform and global environmental governance.
He currently serves on the Steering Committee of the Climate Governance Commission and the Academic Council of the European Center for Peace and Development, and chairs the Religion and Environment Working Group of the G20 Interfaith Forum. A lifelong member of the Bahá’í Faith, he has also devoted significant attention to the relationship between science, ethics, religion, and humanity’s responsibility for the planet.
To welcome Dr. Dahl to the National Advisory Council, Drea Bergman, CGS Secretariat member, asked him about the future of global governance, world federation, and our shared environment.
Drawing on your decades of experience in environmental governance and the United Nations, why do you believe stronger forms of global governance, including the idea of democratic world federation, are increasingly necessary to address shared challenges such as climate change, biodiversity loss, and other planetary risks?
From a science perspective, our planet is a single Earth System with one atmosphere, a united ocean system, complex interrelated ecosystems with high biodiversity, powered largely by the flow of solar energy, which together maintain an environment suitable for life, including our own.
We have invented technologies for communications, transportation, industry, agriculture, economic transactions and trade that have eliminated all barriers within that Earth system, making world unity both possible and necessary, yet we are trapped in a governance paradigm of national sovereignty from earlier times, competing for resources and generating conflicts that could destroy our civilization.
The only reasonable solution is to create global governance for the common good that is the Earth system we depend on, while implementing subsidiarity in governance to ensure national autonomy in meeting needs responsibly within those planetary boundaries, and empowering local communities to read their own reality, assess their capacities and resources, and undertake the necessary social actions.
We need values that accept a higher human purpose than material satisfaction, building on our capacity to cooperate, to be trustworthy, to refine our character, and to place service to others above selfish interest. Above all, we must accept that we are a single human family in all our diversity, building a multi-level governance system including world federation in which all participate, that leaves no one behind.
Drawing on your work with UNEP and decades of experience in global environmental governance, what opportunities do you see for strengthening international institutions and cooperation to more effectively address shared environmental challenges and build a more sustainable future?
We have inherited international institutions that are trapped in the paradigm of national sovereignty, expressed as the consensus rule in negotiations and the veto in the Security Council, ignoring the science and holding us to the lowest common denominator defended by political power and vested interests.
Even when agreement is reached, there is no power of implementation. Ideally, if the great majority of nations acknowledge that the multilateral system is broken, they should call for a UN Charter replacement conference and build a better system on top of the present one, even if some countries hold back for a while. We can keep all that we have learned from the UN and conventions while finally making progress in resolving environmental challenges.
There is already a lot being done at the regional level and within various environmental agreements, but still within silos, and on some issues we are going backwards. It may take a global crisis situation to finally overcome the resistance and blockages, whether the climate catastrophe now unfolding, an economic collapse as the debt bubble bursts, or even a third world war, but we should prepare to move forward quickly to save what we can of the remaining environmental resources and services, and regenerate them as quickly as possible.
Our proposal to make Earth System governance the fourth pillar of the UN, and to create an effective global environment agency upgraded from UNEP, go in this direction. We should prepare for the worst, but also retain hope in a better future.
We are honored to welcome Dr. Arthur Lyon Dahl to the CGS National Advisory Council and look forward to drawing on his extraordinary experience as CGS continues exploring how stronger global institutions can contribute to a more peaceful, just, democratic, and sustainable world community.
Stay connected
Subscribe to CGS eNews for a monthly email on what the movement is doing and what comes next.